1. Quality and impact of the paper selection:
2. Was the background/introduction sufficient to introduce the paper?
3. Student's interpretation and ability to explain the data:
4. Slides, organization, and flow of presentation:
5. Elements of presentation style that could be improved:
6. Did the presenter field questions appropriately?
7a. What were the strengths of this presentation?
7b. What were the weaknesses of this presentation?
(Your name will not be shared with the student and will be kept confidential.)