$FL2@(#) SPSS DATA FILE MS Windows Release 10.0.5 spssio32.dll V;Y@17 Sep 0214:25:25 CARDNO CARD NUMBER CODERID CODER ID NUMBER VOLNO SCRA VOLUME NUMBER BEGNPAGESCRA BEGINNING PAGE NUMBER ENDPAGE SCRA ENDING PAGE NUMBER REPTTYPETYPE OF CASE/DISPUTE REPORT "@DOCKETIDDOCKET IDENTIFICATION NUMBERDIVISIONDIVISION DECIDING "@PETITNERNAME OF PETITIONER/APPELLEE    RESPONDNNAME OF RESPONDENT/APPELLANT   SEQUNO SEQUENCE NUMBER - CARD 1CARDNO2 CARD NUMBER - CARD 2CODERID2CODER ID NUMBER VOLNO2 SCRA VOLUME NUMBER BEGNPAG2SCRA BEGINNING PAGE NUMBER DECMONTHMONTH OF DECISION REPORTDECDATE DATE OF DECISIONDECYEAR YEAR OF DECISIONACTNTYPETYPE OF ACTION X@CTIMMEDI COURT/AGENCY OF IMMEDIATE ORIGIN@CTINITIOCOURT OF INITIAL ORIGIN @PROVIMED!PROVINCE/CITY OF IMMEDIATE ORIGIN @PROVINITPROVINCE/CITY OF INITIAL ORIGIN @OUTCIMEDIMMEDIATE ORIGIN OUTCOME"@OUTCINITINITIAL ORIGIN OUTCOME "@ISSUE SUBSTANTIVE ISSUE OF CASE @BEGNYEARYEAR OF THE CASE/DISPUTE BEGAN X@SEQUNO2 SEQUENCE NUMBER - CARD 2CARDNO3 CARD NUMBER - CARD 3CODERID3CODER ID NUMBER VOLNO3 SCRA VOLUME NUMBER BEGNPAG3SCRA BEGINNING PAGE NUMBER ATTYPLTFATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF    ATTYRESPATTORNEYS FOR RESPONDENT   OUTCPLTFPLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT OUTCOME"@OUTCUDOGUPPERDOG/UNDERDOG OUTCOME "@OUTCGOVTGOVERNMENT AGENCY OUTCOME "@SEQUNO3 SEQUENCE NUMBER - CARD 3CARDNO4 CARD NUMBER CODERID4CODER ID NUMBER VOLNO4 SCRA VOLUME NUMBER BEGNPAG4SCRA BEGINNING PAGE NUMBER OPINWRTR!MAJORITY OPINION WRITER (PONENTE) BENGZONCVOTE OF CESAR BENGZON "@PADILLASVOTE OF SABINO PADILLA "@ANGELO VOTE OF FELIX BAUTISTA ANGELO "@JUGO VOTE OF FERNANDO JUGO LABRADORVOTE OF ALEJO LABRADOR "@CONCEPCRVOTE OF ROBERTO R. CONCEPCION "@REYESJ VOTE OF J. B. L. REYES "@BARRERA VOTE OF JESUS G. BARRERA"@DAVID VOTE OF JOSE GUTIERREZ DAVID"@DIZON VOTE OF ARSENIO P. DIZON"@PAREDES VOTE OF JOSE MA. PAREDES"@DELEON VOTE OF DIONISIO DE LEONNATIVIDAVOTE OF FELIPE NATIVIDADREGALA VOTE OF ROBERTO REGALA MAKALINTVOTE OF QUEREBE MAKALINTAL ZALDIVARVOTE OF CALIXTO ZALDIVARBENGZONJVOTE OF JOSE P. BENGZON SANCHEZ VOTE OF CONRADO V. SANCHEZ CASTRO VOTE OF FRED RUIZ CASTROANGELES VOTE OF EUGENIO ANGELES FERNANDOVOTE OF ENRIQUE M. FERNANDO CAPISTRAVOTE OF FRANCISCO R. CAPISTRANO TEEHANKEVOTE OF CLAUDIO TEEHANKEE BARREDO VOTE OF ANTONIO P. BARREDO VILLAMORVOTE OF JULIO V. VILLAMOR MAKASIARVOTE OF FELIX V. MAKASIAR ANTONIO VOTE OF FELIX Q. ANTONIOESGUERRAVOTE OF SALVADOR V. ESGUERRAFERNANDEVOTE OF ESTANISLAO A. FERNANDEZ MUNOZPALCECELIA MUNOZ PALMA AQUINO RAMON C. AQUINO CONCEPCHHERMOGENES CONCEPCION, JR. MARTIN RUPERTO G. MARTIN SANTOS VOTE OF GUILLERMO S. SANTOS FERNANDRVOTE OF RAMON C. FERNANDEZ GUERREROVOTE OF JUVENAL K. GUERRERO ABADSANVVOTE OF VICENTE ABAD SANTOS DECASTROVOTE OF PACIFICO P. DECASTROHERRERA "VOTE OF AMEURFINA MELENCIO HERRERA ERICTA VOTE OF VICENTE G. ERICTA PLANA VOTE OF EFREN I. PLANA ESCOLIN VOTE OF VENICIO T. ESCOLIN VASQUEZ VOTE OF CONRADO M. VASQUEZ RELOVA VOTE OF LORENZO RELOVA GUTIERREVOTE OF HUGO E. GUTIERREZ DELAFUEN!VOTE OF BUENAVENTURA DE LA FUENTE CUEVAS VOTE OF SERAFIN R. CUEVAS ALAMPAY VOTE OF NESTOR B. ALAMPAY PATAJO VOTE OF LINO M. PATAJO FERIA VOTE OF JOSE Y. FERIA YAP VOTE OF PEDRO L. YAPFERNAN VOTE OF MARCELO N. FERNAN NARVASA VOTE OF ANDRES R. NARVASCRUZ VOTE OF ISIGANI A. CRUZ PARASE VOTE OF EDGARDO L. PARASFELICIANVOTE OF FLORENTINO P. FELICIANO GANCAYCOVOTE OF EMILIO A. GANCAYCO PADILLATVOTE OF TEODORO R. PADILLA BIDIN VOTE OF ABDULWAHID A. BIDIN SARMIENTVOTE OF ABRAHAM F. SARMIENTOCORTES VOTE OF IRENE R. CORTES PARASR VOTE OF ROBERTO PARAS UNANIMOUUNANIMITY OF DECISION "@SEQUNO4 SEQUENCE NUMBER - CARD 4SEQUNO5 SEQUENCE NUMBER- CODE 2 VOLNO5 VOLUME NUMBER BEGNPAG5BEGINNING PAGE NUMBER ACTNTYP2TYPE OF ACTION OUTCIME2OUTCOME OF IMMEDIATE ORIGIN OUTCINI2"OUTCOME OF COURT OF INITIAL ORIGIN ISSUE2 SUBSTANTIVE ISSUE OF CASE CTIMEDO2COURT/AGENCY OF IMMED ORIGINCTINITO2COURT/AGENCY OF INIT ORIGIN OUTCPLT2PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT OUTCOME"@OUTCUDG2UPPERDOG/UNDERDOG OUTCOME "@OUTCGOV2GOVERNMENT AGENCY OUTCOME "@SEQUNO6 SEQUENCE NUMBER - CODE 3VOLNO6 VOLUME NUMBER BEGNPAG6BEGINNING PAGE NUMBER ACTNTYP3TYPE OF ACTION OUTCIME3OUTCOME OF IMMEDIATE ORIGIN OUTCINI3"OUTCOME OF COURT OF INITIAL ORIGIN ISSUE3 SUBSTANTIVE ISSUE OF CASE CTIMEDO3COURT/AGENCY OF IMMED ORIGINCTINITO3COURT/AGENCY OF INIT ORIGIN OUTCPLT3PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT OUTCOME"@OUTCUDG3UPPERDOG/UNDERDOG OUTCOME "@OUTCGOV3GOVERNMENT AGENCY OUTCOME "@MAJISSUEMajor Substantive Issue X@MAJISSU3Major Issue 3rd Coding X@MAJVOTE Number of Majority VotesDISSENT Number of Dissents FILTER_$DECYEAR = 84 (FILTER) ?Acosta, Ernesto@ Lee, Rona @Loculan, Dinah @Mendez, Carmencita @Urpilla, Brenda@ Rivas, Rene @Tabigue, Apolgio @Agustin, Joaquin "@ Catli, Madel $@Doble, Criselda&@Juan, Lillibeth(@Melchor, Narciso *@Paras, Victoria,@Renslayan, Nanette .@Tandaguen, Evangelin 0@ Yumul, Eric 1@Vitto, Teresita2@de los Santos, Veron 3@Aquino, Crispin4@Bascug, Consolacion 5@ Portes, Lani 6@Tenefrancia, Suzette 7@Aquino, Monica 8@ Pangan, Tess 9@Haynie, Stacia L. ?*Regular, L prefix full case/dispute report @Administrative case report @Admin/bar Matter Rpt @L prefix RESOLUTION @Administrative case RESOLUTION @'Administrative or Bar matter RESOLUTION"@Not Ascertainable ?FIRST DIVISION @SECOND DIVISION@EN BANC@THIRD DIVISION "@NOT APPLICABLE ?Acosta, Ernesto@ Lee, Rona @Loculan, Dinah @Mendez, Carmencita @Urpilla, Brenda@ Rivas, Rene @Tabigue, Apolgio @Agustin, Joaquin "@ Catli, Madel $@Doble, Criselda&@Juan, Lillibeth(@Melchor, Narciso *@Paras, Victoria,@Renslayan, Nanette .@Tandaguen, Evangelin 0@ Yumul, Eric 1@Vitto, Teresita2@de los Santos, Veron 3@Aquino, Crispin4@Bascug, Consolacion 5@ Portes, Lani 6@Tenefrancia, Suzette 7@Aquino, Monica 8@ Pangan, Tess $4 ?JANUARY@FEBRUARY @MARCH @APRIL @MAY @JUNE @JULY @AUGUST "@ SEPTEMBER $@OCTOBER&@NOVEMBER (@DECEMBER "$@OJ/SCA amb/diplmat &@OJ/SCA certiorari *@OJ/SCA prohibition ,@OJ/SCA mandamus.@OJ/SCA quo warranto 0@OJ/SCA habeas corpus 1@OJ/SCA injunct. only 3@OJ/SCA basis unclear 5@APPEAL constit'ality 6@APPEAL legality tax 7@APPEAL Court juris. 8@APPEAL life/death 9@APPEAL only q. law =@APPEAL basis unclear ?@CERT Const'ality @@CERT legality of tax @@CERT Court juris. A@CERT life/death A@CERT only q. law C@CERT basis unclear D@Review const'ality E@Review legality tax E@Review Court juris. F@Review life/death F@Review only q. law H@Review basis unclear T@Admin case Lawyers @T@Admini case Judges T@Admin case employee @U@Bar Exams Case U@Integ Bar regulation V@Assignment of judges W@Change of venueX@Not Ascertainable {INAPPROP/NOT APPLIC Y@Off of President [@ President ^@Executive Secy @^@Deputy Exec Secy ^@Asst Exec Sec Legis ^@AssExSec Intnl Affs @_@Adminr Econ Coord `@Asst Exec Secy @`@Pres Spec Counsel a@ Cabinet Secy @b@Pres Asst Legalb@OIC Polit Affairs d@Spec Couns to Pres @e@ Pres Appt Off f@Pres Mngment Staff g@ Protocol Off i@Admin Gen Affs Offc @j@ Finance Off k@Off of Press Secy l@Bur Ntnl Frgn Info n@Bur of Broadcast n@PTV-4 @n@Phil News Agency @o@Phil Info Agency @p@Polit Affairs Off p@Engineer's Office q@ Legal Office r@Malacanang Clinic r@Pres Comm Good Gvt `s@Ntnl Econ Dev Auty y@Off of Vice Pres y@Vice President @z@V President's Staff pz@Bd Rev Motion Pics @@Dpt Agrarian Reform P@Ntnl Land Ref Coun @Secy/Minr Ag Reform @@USecy Agrarn Reform @Asst Sec/Min Ag Ref @Division Chf Ag Ref 0@Bur Ag Lgl Asstnce @Bur Land Acqui/Dist Ё@Bur of Resettlement @Ctr Op Land Trnsfer @Dpt of Agriculture @Secy/Minister Agric `@USecy/Deputy Agric @Asst Sec/Min Agric @Sctn Chiefs Agric P@Bur Plant Industry @Agric Training Inst Ȅ@Bur Agric Extension @Bur Soils Water Mgt @@Bur Animal Industry @Bur Agric Stats@Bur Agric Coop Dev 0@Bur Fish Aq Res @Phil Tobacco Admin І@Phil Virgnia Tob Ad @Phil Virgnia Tob Bd H@Phil Coconut Auty p@Fertz Pestcide Auty @Phil Dairy Corpȇ@Rice Corn Admin@Phil Sugar Inst@Ntnl Nutrition Coun `@Phil Fish Dev Auty @Fiber Dev Auty @Ntnl Meat Insp Comm P@Phil Cotton Corp @Ntnl Board, SEAFDEC @Green Rev Expn Prog @@Livestock Dev Coun h@Ntnl Irrig Admin @Ntnl Artif Rain Prg @Pres Ctte Ag Credit @Dpt Budgt Mgmt p@Secy/Min Budgt Mgmt @USc/Dpy Min Bgt/Mgt @Asst Sc/Min Bgt/Mgt `@Bur Bgt Op Ntl Gv A @Bur Bgt Op Ntl Gv B @Bur Bgt Op Gv Corps P@Reg Coor Staff-Luzn @Rg Crd Stf Vis/Mind @Research Staff @@Bur Actg Fin Nt Gv @Bur Systems Proc @Bur Comp/Pstn Class @Bur Fiscal Planning @@Bur Actg Fin Loc Gv h@Bur Org Prod Imprvm @Legal Legis Bur@Admin Services @Forgn Asst Proj Bur @Gv Corps Acctg Bur 0@Procurement Service X@Bur Bgt Op Loc Gvt @Dpt Ed Cultu Sports @Secy/Min Ed Cul Spt @UScy/Dpy Min Ed C S 8@Ast Sc/Min Ed C Spt `@Ad Sv ECS Dv Chiefs @Fin Mgt ECS Dv Chfs @Plng Sv ECS Dv Chfs ؓ@Child Youth Rec Ctr @Pop Ed Program Unit (@Frg Std Spec Ac Off P@Tchrs Camp Baguio x@Inst Materials Coun @Bur Elem Education Ȕ@Bur Sec Education @Bur Higher Learning @Bur Phy Ed Scl Spts @@Bur Tech/Voc Educ h@ Bur Non-Frml @Schl Hlth/Nutrn Ctr @Ntl Ed Test Res Crr @Inst Phil Languages @Ntnl Hist Inst 0@ Ntnl Library X@ Ntnl Museum p@Dpt Engy Env Nat Res @Scy/Min En Env N Res @UScy/Dpy Mins EENR @Asst Sec/Min EENR @Bur Forest Dev $@Reforestn Admin8@Forest Res Inst`@ Bur Lands @Bur Mines Geo-Sci @Oil Industry Comm @Minrl Reserv Dev Bd ؘ@Nat Res Mgmt Ctr @Ntnl Ctte Geo Sci (@T Force Pawikan Cnl P@Nat Res Dev Corp x@Wood Indus Dev Auty @ Dpt Finance @Secy/Min Finance @UScy/Dpy Min Financ @Asst Sec/Min Financ 0@Bureau Customs X@B Econ Intel/Inves @Fiscal Incen Rev Bd @Insurance Comm Л@Bur Intrnl Revnue @ Bur Treasury @Phil Crop Insu Corp H@P For Loan Gte Corp p@Ntl Tax Res Ctr@Ctl Bd Assess @Dpt Foreign Affairs ؝@Secy/Min For Affs @UScy/Dpy Min For Aff (@Asst Sc/Min For Aff P@Off Amer Affairs x@Off Asian Pac Affs @Off European Affs Ȟ@Off Fiscal Services @Off For Service Adm @Of Insp/Intl/Lgl Sv @@Off Mid E/Afr Affs h@Off Pers Mgt Servs @ Off Protocol @Off Pub Aff-For Aff @Off U N/Intl Orgs @Off Consular Servs @Foreign Serv Inst ,@Bd Overse Econ Prom h@Bur Immig/Deportatn @ Dpt Health @Secy/Min HealthЦ@USecy/Dpy Mins Hlth @Asst Sec/Min Hlth @Bur,Dvs,Servs Hlth @Hospitals Clinics p@ Dpt Justice @Secy/Min Justice @UScy/Dpy Min Justice @Asst Sc/Min Justice @Ctzn Legal Asst Off ԧ@Ntnl Bur Investig @Land Deeds Regis Ad @Land Regis Comm@Ntnl Pros Service @Probation Admin$@ Bur Prisons 8@Com Settlmt Lnd Prb L@Bd Pardons Parole `@Off Solic General t@Off Gvt Corp Counsl @Fiscals@ Police Comm @Dpt Labor Employmnt @Secy/Min Labor Empl (@UScy/Dpy Min Labor <@Ast Sec/Min Labor P@Bur Local Employ d@Bur Labor Relations x@Bur Women Yng Wrkrs @Bur Working Condtns @Bur Rural Workers @Ntl Manpwr Yth Coun ȩ@Ins Lbr Manpwr Serv ܩ@Employees Comp Comm ީ@Workmens Comp Comm @Reg Wk/Emp Comp Hrg @Ntnl Wage Coun @Ntl Labor Rel Comm @Reg Labor Hrg Offr @Phil Overs Empl Ad ,@Welf Fund Overs Wkr @Dpt Local Govt @Secy/Min Local Gvt @USc/Dpy Min Lcl Gv ̪@Ast Sec/Min Locl Gv @Bur Local Gv Dev @Ntnl Bgy Op Off@Ct Ntl Gv Aid L Gv @Jt Comm Lcl Gv Pers 0@Barangay Roads Prg X@Provincial Govts n@Provincial Governor p@Provincial Vice Gov r@Prov Bd/Councilt@Prov Bd/Coun Mbmrs v@Prov Atty NOT Fiscl x@Prov Finan officers z@Prov Records Offcrs |@Prov Disc/Cmplt Agy ~@Other Prov Offrs @Local Governments @ City Mayor @City Vice Mayor@ City Council @City Coun member(s) @Cty Police/Pol Ofcr @ City Attorney @City Finan Officers @City Records Ofcrs @City Disc/Cmplt Agy @Other City Offrs @ Munic Mayor @Munic Vice Mayor @ Munic Council @Munic Coun Mbrs@Munic Police/Ofcr @Munic Attorney @Munic Finan Ofcrs @Munic Records Ofcrs @Munc Disc/Cmplt Agy @Other Munic Officrs @ Bo/Bgy Mayor @Bo/Bgy Vice Mayor @Bo/Bgy Council «@Bo/Bgy Council Mbrs ī@Bo/Bgy Police/offcr ƫ@Bo/Bgy Attorneyȫ@Bo/Bgy Finan Ofcrs ʫ@Bo/Bgy Records Ofcr Ϋ@Other Bo/Bgy Ofcrs @Dpt Ntnl Defense 4@Secy/Min Nat Defens H@UScy/Dpy Min N Def \@Asst Sec/Min N Def p@Armed Forces Phils @Phil Air Force @ Phil Army @Phil Constabulary @ Phil Navy @Integ Ntnl Police @Dpt Pub Wrks Hwys ĭ@Secy/Min Pub Wrks ح@UScy/Dpy Min P Wrks @Asst Sec/Min P Wrks @Bur Construction @ Bur Design (@ Bur Equipment <@Bur MaintenanceP@Matrls Qual Control d@Spec Bldg Mgt Off x@Ntnl Irrig Admin @Ntnl Water Res Cncl @Bd Power Waterworks @Pasig Rver Dev Coun @Lcl Water Util Adm Ȯ@Phil Ports Autyܮ@Urban Projects Off @Bdge Arpt Mvt Areas @@Dpt Social Welf Dev T@Scy/Min Soc Welf Dv h@USc/Dp Min Soc Welf |@AstSec/Min Soc Welf @Bur Child Yth Welf @Bur Disabled Welf @Bur Family Com Welf ̯@Bur Women's Welfare @Bur Pub Asst Liason @Coun Welfare Chldn @Population Commh@ Dpt Tourism r@Secy/Min Tourism |@USecy/Dpy Mins Trsm @Asst Sec/Min Trsm @Phil Tourism Auty @Bur Tourism Serv @Phil Convention Bur @Duty Free Phils@Bur Tourism Promtn 0@Dpt Trade Industry :@Secy/Min Trade Indu D@UScy/Dp Mn Trad/Ind N@Ast Sc/Min Trad/Ind X@Bur Domestic Trade b@Bur Foreign Trade l@Bur Industrial Dev v@Product Stndrd Agy @ Patent Off @Dpt Transp Commun @Secy/Min Tpt Commun @USc/Dp Mn Tpt Commn @Ast Sc/Mn Tpt Commn @Bd Transportation @Bur Air Transportn !@Civil Aviation Bd *@Land Transport Off +@Land Transp Comm ,@Public Service Comm 4@Ntl Telecom Comm >@Bur Posts (BOP)H@Phil Ntnl LinesR@Toll Regulatory Bd \@Off Transp Coops f@Mla Intl Airpt Auty p@Maritime Indus Auty q@Ntnl Seaman's Board z@Transp Training Ctr @Phil Ports Auty@Metro Mla Trans Crp @Lgt Rail Trans Auty @Phil Ntnl Railways @Civil Service Comm @Civil Serv Bd Appl @Profes Regul Comm @ Comm on Audit @Auditor General@Comm on Elections @Comm Human Rights ij@Price Control Coun γ@Reparations Comm Z@ Central Bank _@Phil Ntnl Bank d@Cultural Ctr Phils n@Dev Bank Phils x@Expt Proc Zone Auty @Food Terminal Inc @Gvt Serv Ins Sys @Sugar Regul Admin @Techn Resource Ctr @Phil Atom Egy Comm @Sec Exchange Comm @Ntl Electrif Admin ô@Ntnl Housing Auty ȴ@Ntl Pollut Ctrl Com Ҵ@Lcl Water Util Adm ܴ@Ntl Cottg Ind Auty @Ntl Env Protec Coun @Social Secur Comm p@ Congress z@Senate @House Representvs @Batasang Pambansa Է@ Comm on Appts b@Supreme Court O. J. l@Court Appeals v@Intermed Appel Crt @Reg Trial Court @Ct First Instance @Circ Criminal Court @Metro Trial Court ƻ@ City Court л@Munic Trial Court ڻ@Municipal Court@Juv-Domes Rel Ct @Munic Circ Trial Ct @Justice of Peace. @Court Tax Appeals *@Court Indus Rels 4@Court Agr Relations 5@Court Agr Reform @Sandiganbayan @Shari'a District Ct @Shari'a Circuit Ct @Mil Ct/Comm-Non-Mil @Mil Courts Martial @Peoples' Courts@ Tanodbayan @@Admin case lawyers @Admin case judges @Admin case emplyes @Bar exams cases@Integ Bar regul@NOT ASCERTAINABLE Metro Manila-Uspecif $@City of Manila 4@ Quezon City >@ Caloocan City D@ Pasay City I@Metro Mla NOT City N@Makati Q@Malabon R@Navotas@R@San Juan R@ Mandaluyong R@Marikina @T@Pasig T@ Paranaque T@ Las Pinas U@ Muntinglupa @U@Pateros U@Taguig U@ Valenzuela Y@Region 1 Unspecif. [@Abra ^@Benguet excl Baguio @^@Baguio City,Benguet @_@Mount Prv bef Div @`@ Ilocos Norte ``@Laoag City, Ilo N a@ Ilocos Sur b@La Union d@Mount Prv aft Div @e@ Pangasinan `e@Dagupan City, Pang e@San Carlos, Pang i@Region 2 Unspecif. l@Ifugao n@Isabela@o@Kalinga-Apayao @p@ Nueva Vizcaya p@Quirinor@Region 3 Unspecif. `s@Bataan t@Bulacant@ Nueva Ecija t@Cabanatuan, N Ecija t@Palayan, N Ecija t@San Jose, N E Ecija @u@ Pampanga Pu@Angeles City, Pamp u@ Zambales u@Olongapo City, Zamb v@Tarlac y@Region 4 Unspecif. Py@Aurora y@ Batangas y@Batangas City y@Lipa City, Batangas y@Cavite z@Tagaytay City, Cav z@Cavite City, Cavite z@Trece Martires, Cav @z@Laguna Pz@San Pablo. Laguna z@ Marinduque z@Occidental Mindoro 0{@Oriental Mindoro {@Palawan {@Puerto Princesa, Pal {@Quezon {@Lucena City, Quezon |@Rizal p|@Romblon@@Region 5 Unspecif. @Albay @Legazpi City, Albay @@Camarines Norte@ Camarines Sur @Naga City, Cam Sur @Iriga City, Cam Sur @ Catanduanes 0@Masbate@ Sorsogon @Region 6 Unspecif. @Aklan `@Antique@Capiz @Roxas City, Capiz @Iloilo @Iloilo City, Iloilo P@Negros Occidental X@Bacolod City, N Oc `@San Carlos, Negr Oc h@Cadiz City, Negr Oc p@Bago City, Negr Oc x@La Carlota, Negr Oc @Silay City, Negr Oc @Region 7 Unspecif. 0@Bohol 8@Tagbilaran, Bohol @Cebu @Cebu City, Cebu@Danao City, Cebu @Lapu-Lapu City,Cebu @Mandaue City, Cebu @Toledo City, Cebu І@Negros Oriental؆@Bais, Negros Or@Canalon, Negros Or @Dumaguete, Negr Or @Siquijor @Region 8 Unspecif. P@Leyte X@Tacloban City,Leyte `@Ormoc City, Leyte @Southern Leyte @ Eastern Samar @@Northern Samar @Samar @Calbayog City,Samar @Region 9 Unspecif. p@Basilan@Sulu Ȍ@Jolo @ Tawi-Tawi `@Zamboanga del Norte h@Dapitan City, Z d N p@Dipolog City, Z d N @Zamboanga del Sur @Zamboanga Cty, Z d S @Pagadian City, Z d S @@Region 10 Unspecif. h@Agusan before div. @Agusan del Norte @Butuan, Agusan d N @Agusan del Sur @Bukidnon @@Camiguin h@Misamis Occidental l@Oroquieta, MMis Oc p@Ozamis City, Mis Oc t@Tangub City, Mis Oc @Misamis Oriental @Cagayan de Oro, M Or @Gingoog City, Mis Or @Surigao del Norte @Surigao City, Sur N ̐@Surigao before Div 0@Region 11 Unspecif. D@Davao before Div X@Davao del Norte@Davao Oriental @ Davao del Sur @Davao City, Dav Sur Б@South Cotabato ԑ@General Santos, S Co @Surigao del Sur@Region 12 Unspecif. @Lanao del Norte @Iligan City, Lan N @ Lanao del Sur @Marawi City, Lan S 8@ Maguindanao <@Cotabato City, Mag L@Cotabato before Div `@North Cotabato @Sultan Kudarat \@NOT ASCERTAINABLE  Inappropriate ?Wholly Reversed@Substantaly Modified @Largely Affirmed @Wholly Affirmed"@Not Ascertainable |}?DUE PROCESS OF LAW @EQUAL PROTECTION @SEARCH AND SEIZURE @PRIVACY@ADMISS OF EVIDENCE @FREEDOM OF SPEECH @FREEDOM OF THE PRESS @FREEDOM OF ASSEMBLY "@PETITION $@ESTABLISH RELIGION &@FREEDOM OF RELIGION (@NO RELIGIOUS TEST *@LIBERTY OF ABODE ,@FREEDOM OF TRAVEL .@ACCESS TO PUB INFO 0@FORM UNIONS/ASSOCS 1@EXPROP PRIV PROPERTY 2@SANCTITY CONTRACTS 3@POOR ACCESS COURTS 4@SPEEDY DISPOSITION 5@INVOLUNTARY SERV 6@IMPRISONMENT DEBT 7@EX POST FACTO LAWS 8@BILLS OF ATTAINDER >@VOTE (SUFFRAGE) i@CONSTIT PROCEDURES @i@ q@OTHER CONST DISPUTES r@NATURLZ./CITIZENSHIP u@IMMIG/DEPORTATION y@ HABEAS CORPUS y@ADEQ LEGAL ASSTNCE y@REMAIN SILENT 0y@COUNSEL @y@TORTURE/INTIMIDATN Py@BEING HELD IN SECRET `y@REASONABLE BAILpy@DUE PROC ARREST/TRL y@PRESUMP INNOCENCE y@HEARD DURING TRIAL y@INFORMED OF CHARGES y@ SPEEDY TRIAL y@IMPARTIAL TRIALy@ PUBLIC TRIAL y@SELF-INCRIMINATION y@POLITICAL DETENTION z@EXCESSIVE FINESz@NONHEINOUS DEATH PEN z@DOUBLE JEOPARDY0z@SUBPOENA WITN/EVID @z@NO TRIAL IN ABSENTIA Pz@CRUEL INHUMAN PUNISH P@ SINGLE MURDER `@MULTIPLE MURDERp@ATTEMPTED MURDER @KIDNAP + MURDER@RAPE + MURDER @ROBBERY + MURDER @KIDNAP+ATTEMP MURDER @RAPE+ATTEM MURDER @ROBBERY+ATTEM MURDER @KIDNAP AND RAPE@ROBBERY AND RAPE @KIDNAP @RAPE @ROBBERY @DRUG TRAFFICKING @SMUGGLING NOT DRUGS (@REBELLION/INSURREC 0@ ARSON+ MURDER 8@ARSON+ATTEM MURDER @@ARSON AND RAPE H@ARSON AND ROBBERY P@ARSON X@ATTTEMPTED RAPEh@ASSAULT@ILLEGAL FIREARMS Ȃ@PUBLIC EMBEZZLEMENT Ђ@PUBLIC CORRUPTION ؂@ PUBLIC FRAUD @PRIVATE EMBEZZLEMENT @ PRIVATE FRAUD @APPT POWER DISPUTE @POSSESSION OF OFFICE p@ LOCAL OFFICES @PROVINCIAL OFFICES @HOUSE REPRESENTAT `@BATASANG PAMBANSA @SENATE @ PRESIDENT P@CONST CONVENTION @VICE PRESIDENT 4@BUSINESS REGULATION Ē@NAT RESOURCES REGUL @AGRIC LAND REFORM T@ TAX VALIDITY d@ TAX PENALTY @DAMAGES SUITS INJURY t@SLANDER LIBEL DAMAGE @CONTRACT DISPUTES ș@PATENT/OTHER PRIV @CREDITOR/DEBTOR$@AGRIC LAND DISPUTES (@URBAN LAND DISPUTES @AG LANDLORD/TENANT D@COMMERC LANDLD/TEN j@RESID LANDLD/TENANT 2@LABOR/MANAGEMENT 4@LABOR UNION DISPUTE @WORKER COMPENSATION @UNSP MARRIAGE/FAMILY ¢@MARRIAGE CONTRACT??? Ģ@BREACH PROMISE MRGE Ƣ@DIVORCE/SEPARATION ʢ@BIGAMY ̢@ADOPTION ΢@ CHILD SUPPORT @ WILLS/ESTATES R@LEGL PROCS SUBST UNK q@CONTEMPT OF COURT շ@REPRIMAND ATTORNEY ַ@DISCIPLINE ATTORNEY ׷@DISBAR ATTORNEY9@REPRIMAND JUDGE:@DISCIPLINE JUDGE @ REMOVE JUDGE @REPRIMAND EMPLOYEE @DISCIPLINE EMPLOYEE @DISMISS EMPLOYEE e@ BAR EXAMS ɹ@INTEGRATED BAR -@ASSIGNMENT JUDGES @NOT ASCERTAINABLE  ~Not Applicable ?Anti-Plaintiff @Partly Anti/Pro Pltf @ Pro Plaintiff "@Not Ascertainable /Not Applicable ? Anti-Underdog @Partly Anti/Pro Udog @ Pro Underdog "@Not Ascertainable 0No Agency is a Party ?Agncy Party-Anti Agy @Agncy Party-Pro Agy "@Not Ascertainable 1? PER CURIAM C@Paras, R. 41-61J@Bengzon, C. 45-66 J@Padilla, S. 46-64 M@Angelo, F. B. 50-66 N@Jugo, F. 50-56 N@Labrador, A. 52-64 O@Concepcion, R. 54-73 P@Reyes, J. 54-72P@Barrera, J. 59-66 Q@David, J. 59-61@Q@Dizon, A. 60-71Q@Paredes, J. 60-65 Q@de Leon, D. 61-67 R@Natividad, F. 62-62 @R@Regala, R. 62-67 R@Makalintal, Q. 62-74 R@Zaldivar, C. 64-74 S@Bengzon, J. 64-68 @S@Sanchez, C. 66-70 S@Castro, F. 66-79 S@Angeles, E. 67-68 T@Fernando, E. 67-85 @T@Capistrano, F. 68-69 T@Teehankee, C. 68-88 T@Barredo, A. 68-82 U@Villamor, J. 70-72 @U@Makasiar, F. 70-85 U@Antonio, F. 72-80 U@Esguerra, S. 72-76 V@Fernandez, E. 73-75 @V@Palma, C. 73-78V@Aquino, R. 73-86 V@Concepcion, H. 75-86 W@Martin, R. 75-78 @W@Santos, G. 77-80 W@Fernandez, R. 77-82 W@Guerrero, J. 77-85 X@Abad Santos, V. 79-8 @X@Decastro, P. 79-84 X@Herrera, A. 79- X@Ericta, V. 81-82 Y@Plana, E. 81-86@Y@Escolin, V. 81-86 Y@Vasquez, C. 82-85 Y@Relova, L. 82-86 Z@Gutierrez, H. 82- @Z@delaFuente, B. 84-86 Z@Cuevas, S. 84-86 Z@Alampay, N. 85-87 [@Patajo, L. 85-86 @[@Feria, J. 86-87[@Yap, P. PLY 86-88 [@Fernan, M. 86- \@Narvasa, A. 86- @\@Cruz, I. 86- \@Paras, E. 86- \@Feliciano, F. 86- ]@Gancayco, E. 87- @]@Padilla, T. 87- ]@Bidin, A. 87- ]@Sarmiento, A. 87- ^@Cortes, I. 87- 7 MEMBER-NOT PART?VOTED WITH MAJORITY @ CONC NO OPIN @CONC IN RESULTS@CONC. SEP OPIN @ RESERVED VOTE @RESERVED DISSENT RIG @DISSENT NO OPIN @ DISSENT OPIN "@NOT ASCERTAINABLE >89:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstu?COMPLETELY UNANIMOUS @UNANIMOUS WITH SEPAR @ONE OR MORE "RESERVE @ NON-UNANIMOUS "@NOT ASCERTAINABLE v&Civil Liberties?Not Used @Con Law@Nat-Citizenship@Crim procedure @ Crim review @Pub Corrup/Fraud @ Priv Fraud @Office Dispute "@ Elec Dispute $@Not Used &@ Reg Business (@Reg Nat Resources *@ Tax Disputes ,@Negligence Suit.@ Slander/Libel 0@ Bus Disputes 1@Cred-Debtor Disputes 2@Land Possession Disputes 3@Ag Llord-Tenant4@Com Llord-Tenant 5@Res Llord-Tenant 6@Labor-Mgmnt Dispute 7@Worker Compensation 8@Marriage-Family9@Probate/Succession :@Civ Proced Only=@Labor-Labor Disputes >@Ag Land Reform N@Contempt of Court N@Disc Attorneys O@ Disc Judges O@ Remov Judge P@Disc Ct Employee @P@Bar Exams Disputes P@Integrated Bar DisputesP@ Assign Judges X@Missing Values &Civil Liberties?Not Used @Con Law@Nat-Citizenship@Crim Procedure @ Crim Review @Pub Corrup/Fraud @ Priv Fraud @Office Dispute "@ Elec Dispute $@Not Used &@ Reg Business (@ Reg NatRes *@ Tax Disputes ,@Negligence Suit.@ Slander/Libel 0@ Bus Disputes 1@Cred-Debtor Disptues 2@Land Possession Disp 3@Ag Llord-Tenant4@Com Llord-Tenant 5@Res Llord-Tenant Disp 6@Labor-Mgmnt Dispute 7@Worker Compensation 8@Marriage-Family9@Probate/Succession :@Civil Procedure=@Labor-Labor Disp >@Ag Land Reform N@Contempt Court N@Disc Attorneys O@ Disc Judges O@ Remove Judges P@Disc Ct Employee @P@Bar Exams Disputes P@Integrated Bar Disp P@ Assign Judges X@Missing Not Selected ?Selected   eniemem19721 Cunanan Tan, Jr.efnieindddb@@@@egniegddehniedmlhmmmmmmmmmeeiesdddd@gddeiesdddgddl@b@leedeny(@hm8@28202 Remotigue fnyOsmena, Jr. d@onud(@b@@ddgn@R@d@y(@Binamin,J. Meer,A. eddhnd@yd(@mmmmmmmmmmmyudd@d@(@dddeddp@d@yuddd(@p@b@edd~mdddenyhm8@H@28239 Magtaos, Jr. Munoz-Palma fnyon d@8@rdddeb@@@gny d@8@Navarrete,Antoniego Gachitorena,Francis dhnyd d@8@mmmmmmmmmmm d@ d@yredd8@p@@gddyre d@8@ddgdddp@@mdddez@hm@33818 Lecar&Sons, Inc.fzTanco, Jr. m~@@@@hhgz@Ē@@Ison,Claro/Ejercito,Gregorio Narvasa,Andres/Ceefhzruz,Mendoza/No @mmmmemeemmemmwh@ddeddR@b@whdd@R@b@edfp~hddekhmq@Pr@37187 Asiatic Integrated Corporatio Alikpalafklgq@udnedv@@gkq@ggdhkq@eelmkmmmmmmm}eddq@ i@@eddueq@dvdggdd@dffdekq@hmPr@37248 City of Manila fkAlikpalalgwdnq@@edvgk@q@ggdhkq@eelmkmmmmmmm}eq@ddedd i@@wedvdq@@ggdddffdekhmq@Pr@37249 Asiatic Integrated Corporatio Alikpalafklgq@wdnedv@@gkq@ggdhkq@eelmkmmmmmmm}eddq@ i@@eddweq@dvdggdd@dffdewef24351 de Vera xfwSantos mzudn@hdxgw@@Bengzon&Bengzon Chan,Manuel eddxhwdgfhedmmxxugddeedx@@uhdd@@eddtthddeweeee49515 Claremont Realty & Brokerage Court of Appealsefweemwdddb@@@@egweBalbastro,ArturoedAlmarioAmador&DavidAgoneiLlola dehwe8@mmmmmmmmmmmmmmeeewddd@b@eddeewdddedd@b@dddevr@ef0s@48264 Switzerland General Insurance fvRamirez fydnr@@gdgv@@r@Camacho.Manuel Bito,Misa&Lozadaeddhv/Gonzales,Greg r@eehemmgr@ddggd@@gddr@@@ggdtrhddevef`u@v@28774 Dev. Bank of the Phil. Court of Appealsfvf`u@oeel@@@ |@@gv`u@gddhv`u@eeedmmmee`u@(@l@@fdfoe`u@efdft(@l@@vgddeuinef46766 Balaquezon EWTU gfuZamora ihe*@@hhggu@2@iEspinas,Jose deLara,Domingo/OeefghufoftheSolicito iheeemmggihheedg2@@i}hg2@*@eefzzhddeuinef46767 Balaquezon EWTU Zamora hfuihehh*@@@2@hguieefhhuiheeemmhhihh2@@eedhi}hgeefz2@*@zhdden}@hg~@39742 Air Manila, Inc.fnCourt of Industrial Relations pfwd}@b@@hdgn@ i@}@eedhnd}@hhlmmmmmmmmmh}@ddegd2@*@whh}@2@b@*@egdfzfedevُhf25778 Joesteel Container Corp.Commonwealth Financing Corp. lfvُm}nnhe@ƻ@ i@lgvُggdlhvُdmmmmmmmmmllُehR@@ƻ@gddlُweegddfR@@ƻ@~dddel w@egPw@61997 RepublicflPartisala oso w@l@@@eeǒgl@@ w@SolicitorGeneral/Singson,Anton Argulles,Enriqueegdhl/Original,Euge w@gdemeegggegeemoh w@ddegd@@oee w@@l@@egdkkoddejܹhe32905 Int'l. Harvester Macleod, Inc Aso Timber Corp.qfjܹeyehl@@@h@@qgjܹRoss,Salcedo,delggRosario,Bito&M Ignacio,Eribertodqhjܹdmmmmmmmqqܹeh@l@@gedqܹehgedu@l@@udddejܽhf36098 Ortigas & Company, Ltd., Part rfjHerrera eyn@ƻ@neergj@ܽgddrhjܽdmmmmmmmmrrܽeeggdr@@l@ܽee@@ƻ@gddttdddejhe28581 San Agustin Orozco ufje}dned@@y@ugjggduhjdmmmmmmmuu{eddR@@gddu}eddggdhy@@hdddevp}@he}@35960 People fvBacani eydp}@b@@edgv@@p}@ggdhvdp}@mmmmmmep}@ddged@b@}eddp}@@@gediidddeihgv@v@36111 Enage Secretary of Justice fihrv@qddd@P@@@giv@eddhidv@mmmmmmmmmmmmmmdddv@@@edddv@ddedd@@dddev@hf@22960 Ipo Limestone Co., Inc. fvMach. & Eng'g. Supp. Co., Inc k}@l@@@nefgv@@Feria,Feria,Lugtu&Lao Diaz,Federico ggdhv@8@mmmmmmmm}h@heddt@l@@hg@@l@@eddrtddeethg|@0|@28377 Uy Tong Silva ftne|@}dngd@@@gt|@ggdht|@8@mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm}gdd|@@@ggd}g|@ddggdu@@uddeej8@hgP@70054 Banco Filipino fjMonetary Board kl}d8@@hdgj@2@8@Quisumbing,Ramon/Quisumbing,No Regalado,Jr,Iniggeehjo/Sycip,Salaza d8@mmmmmmmmmmmm}e8@ddedd2@@}hdd8@2@@geezzdddejhg@@@70054 Banco Filipino Monetary Board fjklX@dgd@@4@gjX@ggehjdX@mmmdmmmmmmmm}hddX@R@@gddgX@ddgddoR@@~dddegq@hgr@71359 Subayno fgPonce Enrile ntdq@b@@edgg@y@q@Surigao,Jr,Alfonso eefhgdq@mmmmmmmmtmq@ddeedy@b@tdddq@y@b@eedhhdddefeihf23039 Ramcar, Inc. Central Bank of the Philippin effeo~dned@@T@egfeedfehfedmmmmmmeee{eddd@@eedeeweddeefqd@@qdddeep@hfq@27520 Globe Wireless Ltd. fePublic Service Commission eydp@,@@hhǏge@@p@gdfhep@8@mmmmmmep@ddgddR@,@eddp@R@,@gdfr~dddeehfq@r@30937 Philippine National BankCourt of Appealsfeeyq@hhl@@@P@@ǐgeq@Medina,Conrado/Mggagtalas,Edgard Chan,Manuel dheq@8@mmmmmmheq@@l@@egehq@fgget@l@@udddeimr@egps@13790 Kua Suy fimCommissioner of Immigration n}nr@@@eegiP@r@mr@delaCruz&delaCruz SolicitorGeneraleedhimeeeer@eeeegglim}er@ddeefu@@m}eddr@u@@eefggnedeueemy@|@8188 People Lacson fuefy@dgd@P@@P@guey@SolicitorGeneralgeNolan,Ricardo/Acuna,Arsenio/GL dhuedky@kleeedeehe|gddy@z@@gedegy@ddgediP@@iigdeue}@em`@15309 People fueCasiano ft{d}@@@e@edgu@@e}@SolicitorGeneralSuyat,Lorenzo mmdhuegeee}@eeeeehe}e}@ddegd@@e}edd}@@@gedkkmddeueemp@@16118 MercaderValila fueftp@oded@@@@R@guep@Mercader,Delfin gdDejaresco,Robustiano dhueep@eeeeeeeeheohddp@t@@eedeohp@ddeed~t@@smddeueЅ@em@15632 People fueArchillafdЅ@@{@edgu@ʢ@eЅ@SolicitorGeneralImperial,Jose/Tigddhuerra,Leon eleeeЅ@eeleehe}eЅ@ddegdʢ@@eeddЅ@ʢ@@gdd||kfdeueem@@14070 Blas Santos fuegi@@ded@ |@@@guei@@Sison,Teofilo/Sigdson,Nicanor delosSantos,Caluag,Pascua&Fel dhueii@@eledhheehi@i@e}edd@@@gddeei@@ddgdd}@@}jederg k@em@l@11870 People frgCruz nt|d k@@ |@gdgr@(@g k@SolicitorGeneralManansala,Cipriaegdhrno/Lao,Jose gelee k@eeehg|g k@ddegd(@@g|gdd k@(@@egdiijedergem~@~@15383 Dizon Arrastiafrgo~@}dnhd@@@grg~@Equia,Hilarion geIbarra,Antonio dhrge~@leeeeeeeehghdd~@@@gedg}h~@ddgedu@@umederg@em؀@16510 Aguilar frgMiranda o}d@@ |@hdgr@@g@Villena,Jose Magsalin,Pedro gedhrgelee@eeeeeehg}h@ddged@@g}hdd@@@geduumedergem@Ё@16849 Francisco Certeza, Sr. frgo`c@@}dhd@ |@@$@grg`c@@Masaquel,A. gdFrancisco,Ricardo dhrge`c@@leeeeeeeeh`c@`c@g}hdd@$@@gddg}h`c@@ddgddv$@@vmedephehm19313 Aytona efphCastilloeewqdb@@ddegp@@heeddehpheehhelelfeeheeheqdddedde@b@heqddd@b@eddlllfdephem@Ќ@13704 Asuncionde Aquino fphhvh@@hhީ@@@@@gphh@@Pastor,Manuel egAmpil,Jr,Marianofhpheh@@eeleeeeehh@h@hhdd@@ީ@egfhhh@@ddegf{@ީ@{ledezkX@em@15639 Industrial, Commercial, Agric fzkBautista`k@h{dX@*@@hdtgz@`k@kX@Velez,H./Anas,M.Recto,Claro/Tuaseedhzon,Magbanua `k@kedeeX@kileeeehk}h`k@`k@X@ddegd2@*@`k@k{hddX@2@*@eeddzkfdekleem20508 Visarra Miraflorefkleitsdddb@@@@egkleBarredo,Antonio edSolicitorGeneraldehkleeehelllllehheeleshdd i@b@eedelesdddeddl@b@ljideimi@eg@j@20079 Merrera fimLiwag mrdi@p@@ddgi@2@mi@Merrera,Roberto SolicitorGeneralggehimiljei@eieeeeehmrdi@dddgge2@mrdddi@2@b@ggezzkedeimegy@ z@17814 Chavez Court of Agrarian Relations fimny@}dhd4@Pz@@@gimy@Castro,Dakila egJustiniano,Julian/Nostratis&Fa dhimey@eeeeeeeelehmhddy@@4@eedm}hy@ddeedw@4@wnedeim8@egh@19275 FerrarenfimAnonuevooy8@l@@@gggi0{@(@m8@Andrada,Nestor/Leido,Jose Padilla,AmbrosioeddhiLawOf mekee8@elieeeehmg8@ggddp@l@@m}gg8@p@l@@gddmmlfdeimhg@@11840 Goquiolay Sycip fimp@dhdb@@@$@gim@Quisumbing,Norbeedrto/Sycip,Sala Calayco,Jose dhime@eleeeeeedehmwhdd@$@b@eddmwh@meddv$@b@@vmedefn m@emm@20741 Gillera ffnFernandez eqd m@b@@ddgf@@n m@Tolentino,ArturoSolicitorGeneralgddhfnelee m@ m@deeeeeehnqd m@ddgdd@b@nqddd m@@b@gddllmedefnemt@u@21776 Jorge Mayor ffnft@rdddb@@@@gfnt@Fernando,Enriqueed/Quisumbing,Jr SolicitorGeneraldhfnet@lleeeelieehnrdddt@@b@gddnrdt@ddgddl@b@lkgdefn{@em |@19981 QuimsingffnTajanglangit fqd{@b@@edgf@@n{@Laurea,Laurea&Asc/Tolentino,Ar LopezVitoLawOf/SgddhfolicitorGenera nelee{@eeeeeeehnqd{@ddgdd@b@nqddd{@@b@gddllnedefnem@P@21991 Asistio San Diego ffngd@@tdxhd@@@gfnd@@Blanco,Jaime/Tayeeag,Enrique CityFiscalofQuezonCity dhfned@@eleieeeeeehd@d@ntdh@@b@@eednthd@@ddeedi@@imedezpem19778 Cromwell Commercial Employees fzpCourt of Industrial Relations m{d*@@hdljgz@2@pOcampo,Vicente Jalandoni&Jamir/egdhzMagbanua,Vidal peekldeeeeeehp{hddeed2@*@p{hdd2@*@eedzzlfdezpem@@20916 Pangasinan Transportation Co. Legaspi fzpp{d@@dhd@@e@@@gzpd@@ChuidianLawOf edAquino,Rodolfo dhzped@@ggldeeeeeehd@d@pohdd@@@eddphd@@ddeddt@@tmedezp@em@20917 Pangasinan Transportation Co. fzpLegaspi d@p{d@@@e@hdgz@@ d@p@ChuidianLawOf Aquino,Rodolfo eddhz d@peg@gldeeeeeehpoh d@ d@@ddedd@@ d@phdd@@@eddttmedeyqhm p@p@19778 Cromwell Commercial Employees Court of Industrial Relations fyqf~ p@wdhd*@@@2@gyq p@eedhyqe p@eklddeeeeehqhdd p@2@*@eedqwh p@heedz2@b@*@zkfdeyqw@emx@24022 Iloilo Palay and Corn Planter fyqFeliciano ggqddw@@ddgy@R@qw@Zulueta,Jose&Gonzales,Ramon SolicitorGeneraleddhyqkew@klkkeeeeehqqdw@dddeef i@qqhddw@ i@eef~fjidexrem@X@23244 Chamber of Agriculture and Na Central Bank fxrjc@@qdddd@@q@gxrc@@Teehankee&Carreoeen/Africa,Jose/ Balboa,Nat./Evangelista,F./Ang fhxrec@@lfeeeeeehhc@c@rqddd@4@b@egdrqdc@@ddegff4@b@omedezsȁ@emx@23825 Pelaez fzsAuditor General p|qdȁ@b@@edgz@ i@sȁ@Zulueta,Gonzales,Paculdo&Asc SolicitorGeneralggfhzseeȁ@eeeekkdlhsqdȁ@ddgge i@b@sqdddȁ@ i@b@ggeffjgdevteme@g@25444 LagumbayCommissions on Elections, et fvtee@dhd@@@@Ǔgvte@Lagumbay,Wencesledao Padilla,Ambrosiodhvtee@keeheleklhthdde@@@edfthe@ddedfm@@mjhdevtw@em y@25577 Guevara fvtInocentes gv}dw@@@e@edgv@R@tw@Padilla,Ambrosio/Guevara,Onofr SolicitorGeneraleddhvteew@heehelddhtsdw@ddeed i@b@tsdddw@@b@edd~lkedeuuhmh@i@18452 Cosio and de Rama Palileo fuuixh@dgdl@@@j@guuh@RectoLawOf eeBengzon,Villegas&Zarragadhuueh@ekkkeleddhuwhddh@j@b@eeduwhh@ddeedyj@b@yhhdepxw@emy@19550 Stonehill fpxDiokno jwqdw@b@@ddggp@xw@Paredes,Poblador,Cruz&Nazareno SolicitorGeneraleddhpAlafriz,Arturo xw@eeeeeeelhxqdw@dgdggfb@xqddgdw@b@ggeddkedenyem@@28089 Lidasan Commission on Elections fnyn}@qdedb@@@ i@gny@Suntay ggBarrios&Fule dhny@eeeeeeeeelhyqedd@q@@ggeyqe@ddggefq@@fmeder{x@hm0@19829 Republicfr{Cokeng ih}dx@b@@hdgr@r@{x@SolicitorGeneralQuisumbing,Norbegefhrrto/Tanada&Car {x@eelkeeelldh{wdx@ddeedr@b@{whddx@r@b@gefggihder{em@H@24039 Padilla City of Pasay fr{j k@@zdhd@@d@gr{ k@@PadillaLawOf eeAsstCityFiscalAvendano,Hermini fhr{ k@@eekeeleeeh k@ k@{zhdd@d@@eed{zh k@@ddeefqd@@qkfdee@v@emx@26430 vda. de Palanca feChua Keng Kian go@v@l@@@nhhgeR@@v@SanJose,M/Cristi,A. CrisologoLawOf eddhe@v@eeeeeeeeeelhe@v@hgddj@l@л@eh@v@j@l@л@ged~ynedeeemX@@21213 Heirs of Gabriel Zari Santos fegX@}dhd@ |@@@geX@Mendiola,Miguel egGatchalian,Nicanor dheX@ileeeeieeehh}hddX@R@@gdd}hX@ddgddt@@tledeeX@em@21214 Heirs of Gabriel Zari feSantos g}dX@@ |@hdge@@X@Mendiola,Miguel Gatchalian,Nicanegdheor X@ileeeeieeehh}hX@ddgddR@@}hddX@@@gddttledeeem@@@27833 GonzalesCommission on Elections fehvH@udhdb@@@ i@geH@Cabigao,F./Advingecula,B. Barrios,Ramon/Sen.Tanada,Loren dheH@ggegkllekglhudddd@ i@eedud@ddeeff i@b@fjideeH@em@29113 Garcia feTeehankee hvqdH@b@@edge@@H@Garcia,Paz SolicitorPardo,Begdheernardo H@eeeeedleeedhqdH@dddeed2@qhddH@py@@eedlhledezem29661 Pineda Claudio lfziqrdhd@@@lgzZafra,Jose/Aquinedo,R. Agrava,Federico/SolicitorGener dlhzelelgeheddhllrddd@b@eddlrhddedfl@@ljfdez@emȂ@28949 Arulla fzEspino j{qd@ƻ@z@hdgz@y@@Familar,GregorioSolicitorGeneraleefhzBarredo,Antoni @eeleeleheddhqd@ddeddR@b@qhe@py@b@@eefhhkfdezem@t@25504 People Ner fzkg@@|dngd@@P@gzg@@Asst.SolicitorGegeneralIbarra,An Vivero-Pareno,Salud/Concepcion dhzg@@eeeedeleeedhg@g@|gdd@P@@ged|gg@@ddgediP@@iledex@emh@31252 Cuenco fxLaya pzqd@@@hdgx@@@Salonga,Ordonez,Yap,Sicat&Asc/ Diokno,Jose/ProveddhxincialFiscalRe @deleleekehh݂qd@heed@b@@qhdd@@@eddmmjgdeyemt@u@27365 Lazo Republic Surety & Insurance C fyet@dned@@@gyt@Lazo,Felix/Sarteee,Jose KohLawOfdhyt@keeeeedeleh}gddt@@@eed}gt@ddeedu@@ukfdeyy@em@21064 J.M. Tuason & Co., Inc. fyLand Tenure Administration fvqdxy@@edugy@y@Araneta,Mendoza&Papa OfoftheSolicitoreefhyGeneral/Pablo, y@kkkgeekelhehqey@ddedf(@@qeddy@(@@edfdvjideyem@@30773 Sta. Maria Lopez fyfv@qdddb@@@@gy@V.E.delRosario&Agdsc/Atienza,Tab SolicitorGeneralMakasiar,Felix dhy@ddedeehhelkhqeded@@ggeqe@dedggel@djfdeyІ@em@31687 Navarro fyVillegasf~wdІ@b@@ddlǵgy@І@eedhyІ@8@mmmmmmllmmhhwhІ@dldeef@whdldІ@@eefddefdeyem(@X@26900 R.C. Ledesma Public Service Commission fyf(@dhd,@@@4@ǽgy(@Cruz,Roman egGracianoC.Regala&Asc fhy(@eeeeeeegelhhdd(@4@,@egfh(@ddegfo4@,@omedevs@em0v@31604 Antonio, Jr. fvCommission on Elections huqds@@@j@edgv@@s@gddhvs@eeeeekllkkhqhs@ddedf@@qhdds@@@edfmmiideuem0z@{@27562 Yarcia City of Baguio fui0z@}dhd@@@gu0z@Yarcia,Juanito eeCityAttorney dhu0z@eeeeeeeleh}hg0z@2@@@eef}h0z@geefr2@@@zledeu~@em@30001 Director of Prisons fuAng Cho Kio j{~@l@@@hhgu |@R@~@SolicitorGeneralMakasiar,Felix Quisumbing,Norbeeddhurto ~@eeelemhdddhh~@hgdfR@l@@hh~@R@l@@edd~~iedeuem@@31501 Sinsuat Pendatunfuj@qdhd@@@@gu@Diokno,Jose edSalonga,Ordonez,Yap,Sicat&Asc fhu@eeeeekellkhÅqgdd@@@eddÅqg@ddedfm@@mjhdesem26549 Lopez {fsCourt of Appealskdl@@gh{gs@t@Salonga,Ordonez,Sicat&Asc eed{hsشeelegeegh{{oggegd{t@l@@؅ggt@l@@egdsskedeshm|@ @31566 Tiglao Commission on Elections fsl|@ded@@@@gs|@eddhs|@eelkleheheehee|@@@@gdde|@egdem@@@mlgdes|@hm @31847 Tiglao fsCommission on Elections ld|@@@edgs@@|@edfhs|@eelkleheheehe|@egdd@@@ee|@@@@gdemmlgderehm32436 In re Subido None efremmwdddb@@@ i@egreSubido,Abelardo dddehredeeeflhflgeheeewdddP@b@eddeewdddeedf i@b@flfderehm32439 In re Hon. Guardson LoodffrNone emmwdb@@ddfgr@ i@eQuezonCityFiscalCortez,Justini dddfhredeeeflhflgehffewdddeddfP@b@ewddd i@b@eedfflfderem32432 Imbong Comelec gfrmowdddb@@@ i@ggrImbong,Manuel edSolicitorGeneralAntonio,Felix fghrkeegiellkehggwdddP@b@eddgwdddeedf i@b@fihderem32433 GonzaleshfrComelec mowdb@@ddhgr@ i@Gonzales,Raul SolicitorGeneraledfhhrAntonio,Felix keegiellkehhhwdddeddhP@b@wddd i@b@eedffihderemd@d@24101 Cuadra Monfort {frmd@}ded@P@@@{grd@Herman,Rodolfo eeTorres,Luis/Tionko,Abraham d{hrd@eeeeedeleeh{{eddd@@@eed{}ed@ddeedr@@rlederq@emt@32546 Badoy, Jr. frComelec nuwdq@b@@ddgr@ i@q@Badoy,Jr,Anacleto SolicitorGeneraleddhrq@fehkflllhehwdq@djdeedb@wdddq@ i@b@eedffjhderemq@t@32551 Badoy, Jr. Comelec frnuq@wdddb@@@ i@grq@Badoy,Jr,Anacletedo SolicitorGeneraldhrq@fehkflllhehwddjdq@b@eedwdq@ddeedf i@b@fjhderv@em@w@32476 del Rosario frComelec nxwdv@b@@ddǛgr@ i@v@delRosario,Simeon SolicitorGeneraledfhrv@eeeiellkgehwdv@d|deedb@wdddv@ i@b@eddffjgderemz@ {@32485 In re: Kay Villegas Kami, Inc None frnzz@wdddb@@@ i@ǟgrz@eddhrz@eeeiellllehwdd{dz@b@eedwdz@ddeedf i@b@fihdep`@emH@26396 Rodriguez fpReyes pq`@@@ |@hhegp@`@Salonga,Ordonez,Yap,Sicat&Asc SolicitorGeneraleefhp`@kleeeeddddhqe`@eggeЂ@@@qhh`@Ђ@@@eeddjhfdepem`@H@27026 Subido Civil Service Board of Appeal fpp`@qhhe@@ |@@gp`@SolicitorPardo,Beeernardo/Daza,A Salonga,Ordonez,Yap,Sicat&Asc fhp`@kleeeeddddhqhdd`@Ђ@@egeqe`@ddggedЂ@@jhfdep`@emH@27027 Subido fpCivil Service Board of Appeal pq`@@@ |@hhegp@`@SolicitorPardo,Bernardo/Daza,A Salonga,Ordonez,eefhpYap,Sicat&Asc `@kleeeeddddhqh`@ddegeЂ@@qedd`@Ђ@@ggedjhfdenemx@y@29421 Artates Urbi fnex@}ded@k@@$@gnx@Jimenez,Bienvenigddo Ubarde,Rogelio/Donato,Alfredo dhnx@eeehekellkehehx@@@@ged}ex@ddggdv@@ukhdem@h@em j@24358 Guevara fmRamos gqdx@h@@hdgm@(@@h@Castillo,Jose Calalang,Maximo eddhm@h@eeeeeeeeleehqe@h@ddged$@@qhdd@h@(@@eddvvnedemempp@0q@27377 Dy Pac Pakiao Workers Union Dy Pac and Co., Inc. fmgpp@gh*@*@@@2@gmpp@Santiago,Carlos ggTanada,Sanchez,Tanada&Tanada/C dhmpp@eeeeeeeleeehogddpp@2@*@eedogpp@ddggdz2@*@znedemr@em t@28783 Reyes fmCarrascogr@l@ڻ@ |@hhgmR@r@Santiago,Fidel Bernabe,Ernesto/eddhmZapata,Mario r@eeeeeeeleedhwer@heddR@l@ڻ@hhr@R@l@ڻ@edd~~medememr@ t@28818 Atengco Court of Appealsfmgr@nnhhl@ڻ@R@gmr@Tan,Acob&Asc edBautista,Angel/Cuna dhmr@eeeeeeeleedhhhr@R@l@@eddhr@hedd~R@l@ڻ@~medemr@em t@29225 Laperal fmCourt of Appealsgr@l@@@hhgm\@R@r@Laurea&Pison Beltran,Beltran&eddhmBeltran r@eeeeeeeleedhhr@hdeddR@l@hhr@R@l@@edd~~medememr@ t@29731 Laperal Court of Appealsfmgr@}eel@@@\@R@gmr@Laurea&Pison gdBeltran,Beltran&Beltran dhmr@eeeeeeeleedhhhdr@R@l@edd}er@egdd~R@l@@~medemr@em t@29753 de la Torre fmEricta gr@l@@@hegm@(@r@Kaamino,Valeriano Ericta,Vicente gddhmr@eeeeeeeleedh}hr@hegd$@l@@}her@$@l@@gddvvmedememr@ t@29970 Dominguez Court of Appealsfmgr@nhel@@@@gmr@Mallari,Carlo/Raedbago,Antonio Gonzales,Guillermo dhmr@eeeeeeeleedhhhr@t@l@@eedhr@heddr@l@@tmedemr@em t@20525 Halili fmCourt of Appealsgr@l@@@hegm |@@r@eddhmr@eeeeeeeleedhhr@heddR@l@@hhr@R@l@@eddr~medememr@ t@31054 Director, Bureau of Building Court of Appealsfmgr@rhel@@@ |@R@gmr@SolicitorGeneraledMakasiar,Felix Sevilla&Aquino dhmr@eeeeeeeleedhrehdr@R@b@gddrhr@hede~R@l@@~medemr@em t@31510 Design Masters, Inc. fmCourt of Appealsgr@l@@@eegm |@@r@Villareal,Navarro&Asc Cruz,Villarin,Lagddhmureta,Ongkiko& r@eeeeeeeleedher@hged@b@@eer@@l@@gddttmedememr@ t@31875 Bragais Court of Appealsfmgr@rdhd@ |@@@gmr@Bragais,AbelardoedRamirez&Ortigas dhmr@eeeeeeeleedhrehr@R@b@@gddrhr@heddtR@l@@~medemr@em t@32395 Tello fmCourt of Appealsgdr@@hdgm@j@r@Cabato,Fernando Asuncion,Isaiah/gddhmMaliaman,Inoce r@eeeeeeeleedher@hged$@l@@ehr@$@l@@gddyvmedeeeml@@m@33097 Baloria de Guzman feml@uhhb@@@`@p@gel@Barrera,Azcuna&QeguibranzaPacatang&MaraonLawOf dhel@eeeeeeeleeehudddl@p@b@edduhl@ddeddmp@@mnedee`m@emn@33125 de Asis feRomero mt`m@b@@@hhge@u@y@`m@David,Juan ProvincialFiscalegdheAglipay,Regido `m@eeeeeelegekhtd`m@ddeedy@b@thdd`m@y@@eedhhmfdeeem@r@@x@21289 Moy Ya Lim Yao Commissioner of Immigration fenh@r@}dned@@r@ge@r@Aruego,Mamaril&Aegsc SolicitorGeneralAlafriz,Arturo ehe@r@kleikeheeekhedd@r@u@@gge}e@r@ddggegu@@gjhdee@y@emPz@23559 Briones feCammayo nh}n@y@@ڻ@nghge@@y@Antiporda,CarlosCammayo,Manuel gedhe@y@kheeelkeheehh@y@gegd@@ڻ@}gg@y@@@ڻ@geduulgdeehm`z@@26112 Republicde los Angeles fenh`z@rdhdb@@@@ge`z@egdhe`z@lkdeeeelhedhrde`z@$@b@l@eddre`z@eeddr@b@l@tjgdee @em@29025 Palisoc feBrillantes nh}dn @@gdge@R@ @Agustin,LeovilloReyes,Honorato/Veddheillareal,Almac @ehdlkkkefeeh}g @ddggd@@}gdd @@@ggd~rjhdeeem@؃@29352 Ramos Central Bank of the Philippin fenh@qdedb@@@4@ge@Carreon,Franciscego/Tumale,Felic SolicitorGeneralAntonio,Felix/ dhe@deelgkgededhqddd@4@b@geeqe@ddggeo4@Z@ojfdee@em(@34150 Tolentino feCommission on ELections ntqd@b@@hdge@R@@Tolentino,ArturoGonzales,Ramon/Pgddheelaez,Emmanuel @ehihhleeehhqd@ddgddP@b@qddd@P@b@gdd~mledeihml@ m@28607 Shell Oil Workers' UnionShell Company of the Phil. fifpl@dddb@@@2@gil@eedhil@eeeeeelleehwgddl@2@b@egdwgl@eggdz2@b@*@zlfdei@emP@31566 Tiglao fiCommission on Elections fd@@@u@edgi@@@Suarez,Amor,Pimentel&Mendoza Barrera,Jesus/Dagddhituin,Hermogene @deklkfeheehh@ddgde@@hdd@@@gdemmjgdeiem@P@31847 Tiglao Commission on Elections fif@ded@@u@@@gi@Suarez,Amor,Pimegdntel&Mendoza Barrera,Jesus/Datuin,Hermogene dhi@deklkfeheehhdd@@@gdeh@ddgdem@@mjgdei@emP@33105 Board of Inspectors of Precin fiSarmiento fd@@@u@edgi@@@Barrera,Jesus/Dagddhituin,Hermogene @deklkfeheehf@ddmdd@@hdd@@@edemmjgdezem25579 Biagtan The Insular Life Assurance,Co nfzg{ded@@e@@@ngzTanopo,Millora,Sgderafica&Sanez Araneta,Mendoza&Papa dnhzkkeeeelheihnn}edd@@eddn}eddeddt@@tjgdezo@hm s@26112 Republicfzde los Angeles hordo@@y@hdgz@Ē@o@eefhzo@kkhffglhedhrho@ddedd$@b@rhho@$@b@@edepvjgdezem0s@u@26971 Central Bank Cloribelfzho0s@qdned@@ i@gz0s@Evangelista,F./Bgeautista,Alfred Tan,Jr,Bienvenido fhz0s@eekekklekeehqedd0s@4@@ggfqe0s@ddggff4@@ojideyem27430 Yap ifyRepubliciu{d@@edigy@r@Palma,Jose SolicitorGeneraleedihyBarredo,Antoni eeedeeekdhii}eddeedir@@}eddr@@eedggjedeyemd@`f@22478 Heirs of Francisco ParcoHaw Dia yfyid@hhl@@@{@$@ygyd@Bunyi,Irineo eddeJoya,Mariano&Navarro&Mortija dyhyd@keedeeekehyyhhd@$@l@@eddyhd@heddv$@l@@vjfdey}@em@31789 Banzon fyCruz judn}@@edgy@@}@Castillo,L.T. DeliaCastro&Asc/ggdhyCastillo,Felib }@eedeeeelddhue}@ddgdd(@@uedd}@@@ggduujedexhmw@}@25885 Luzon Brokerage Co., Inc. Maritime Building Co., Inc. fxlvw@wnhhb@@@@gxw@gddhxw@eegkedelekdhdddw@@b@gddwhw@hgddt@b@@tjgdexЀ@hm@27200 vda. de PrecillafxNarciso lvwЀ@b@@@nemgx@Ѐ@Inton,Antonio/Garcia,Pedro Sevilla,Leandro/gddhxAquino,Ramon/V Ѐ@klkekehefeehdЀ@ddgdd@b@weeЀ@@b@@gdd}}khdei{hm21425 Tiu Vivo hfi{ms}dngd@@r@hgi{Fabre,Engracio eeSolicitorGeneralAlafriz,Arturo dhhi{degeeddleehhh{}hddu@@eefh{}hddggegu@@gjedevem29159 Tatel lfvMunicipality of Virac o|}d@@edlgv@T@Romano,Juanito Tejada,Rey eedlhveeeeleeeehllyeddeeflT@@yeddT@@eefqqledevem29160 Gulf Fibers Corporation Municipality of Virac mfvo|}ded@@@T@mgvRomano,Juanito eeTejada,Rey dmhveeeeleeeehmmyeddT@@eefmyeddeefqT@@qledevw@emz@32613 People fvFerrer podw@@v@edgv@(@w@SolicitorGeneralAntonio,Felix Mutuc,Amelito/Diegdhvokno,Jose w@geeeleeddehoew@d|dged@oed|dw@@gedidkedevemw@z@32614 People Ferrer fvpw@oded@v@@(@gvw@SolicitorGeneralegAntonio,Felix Mutuc,Amelito/Diokno,Jose dhvw@geeeleeddehoed|dw@@gedoew@d|dgedi@dkedeuem@f@35925 Planas rfuCommission on Elections ezdb@@ddrgu@ i@Gonzales,Ramon SolicitorGeneraleefrhuMendoza,Esteli ͢eelehhhehghrrwdddeedr i@b@wddd i@b@eefffmedeuem@f@35929 Sanidad Commission on Elections sfuezdddb@@@ i@sguSanidad,Pablito/eeCatipon,Gerard SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli fshu͢eelehhhehghsswddd i@b@eedswdddeeff i@b@fmedeuem@f@35940 Roxas tfuCommission on Elections ezdb@@ddtgu@ i@JovitoSalonga&Asc/RodrigoLawOf SolicitorGeneraleefthuMendoza,Esteli ͢eelehhhehghttwdddeedt i@b@wddd i@b@eefffmedeuem@f@35941 Monteclaro Commission on Elections ufuezdddb@@@ i@uguQuijano,Arroyo eeSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli fuhu͢eelehhhehghuuwddd i@b@eeduwdddeeff i@b@fmedeuem@f@35942 Ordonez wfuNational Treasurer of the Phi ezdb@@ddwgu@ i@SedfreyOrdonez&Asc SolicitorGeneraleefwhuMendoza,Esteli ͢eelehhhehghwwwdddeedw i@b@wddd i@b@eefffmedeuem@f@35948 Tan Commission on Elections xfuezdddb@@@ i@xguTanada,Lorenzo eeSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli fxhu͢eelehhhehghxxwddd i@b@eedxwdddeeff i@b@fmedeuem@f@35953 Diokno yfuCommission on Elections ezdb@@ddygu@ i@Garchitorena,Francis SolicitorGeneraleefyhuMendoza,Esteli ͢eelehhhehghyywdddeedy i@b@wddd i@b@eefffmedeuem@f@35961 Jimenez Commission on Elections zfuezdddb@@@ i@zguJimenez,Jacinto eeSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli fzhu͢eelehhhehghzzwddd i@b@eedzwdddeeff i@b@fmedeuem@f@35965 Gonzales{fuCommission on Elections ezdb@@dd{gu@ i@Gonzales,Raul SolicitorGeneraleef{huMendoza,Esteli ͢eelehhhehgh{{wdddeed{ i@b@wddd i@b@eefffmedeuem@f@35979 Hidalgo Commission on Elections }fuezdddb@@@ i@}guHidalgo,Ernesto eeSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli f}hu͢eelehhhehgh}}wddd i@b@eed}wdddeeff i@b@fmedeum@emq@22578 National Marketing Corporatio fuFederation of United Namarco e}dnm@@gdgu@@m@GovernmentCorporateCounselMati Gamboa&Gamboa gddhum@dgggehleeeh}gm@ddedd@@}gddm@@@eddttledeuemz@`{@35059 TiongsonCourt of Appealsfufz@}eel@4@@@R@guz@Magat,Bince,Villgdar&Asc Hidalgo,Vicente/Rapanut,Rosari dhuz@keeekleeeehhez@@l@4@egdhz@eegd~@l@4@wkgdeu @em@30380 Galeon fuGaleon fd @@{@edgu@R@ @Trinidad,JoaquinPerez,Remigio gddhu @kleeelleeehe @ddgdd@@edd @@@gdd~}jhdesex@36142 9Javellana The Executive Secretary lfsgqdedb@@@R@lgs{Gonzales,Ramon gdSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli dlhslelelleeeehllqddd i@b@eedlqeddeed~ i@b@fjhdesex@36164 9Tan mfsThe Executive Secretary gqdb@@edmgs@R@LorenzoM.Tanada&Asc SolicitorGeneralgddmhsMendoza,Esteli lelelleeeehmmqdddeedm i@b@qedd i@b@eed~fjhdesex@36165 9Roxas The Executive Secretary nfsgqdedb@@@R@ngsTanada,Salonga,Ogdrdonez,Rodrigo Tolentino,Arturo/SolicitorGene dnhslelelleeeehnnqddd i@b@eednqeddeed~ i@b@fjhdesex@36236 9Monteclaro ofsThe Executive Secretary gqdb@@edogs@R@Arroyo,Joker/Padilla,Rogelio SolicitorGeneralgddohsMendoza,Esteli lelelleeeehooqdddeedo i@b@qedd i@b@eed~fjhdesex@36283 9Dilag The Executive Secretary qfsgqdedb@@@R@qgsRaulM.Gonzales&Agdsc SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli dqhslelelleeeehqqqddd i@b@eedqqeddeed~ i@b@fjhderg@emn@31195 Phil. Blooming Mills Employee {frPhil. Blooming Mills Co., Inc jidg@*@@ed{gr@2@g@Osorio,L./Castillon,P./Espinas Salem,Demetrio&Aggd{hrsc g@deeehlekeh{{eg@ddggd{2@*@eddg@2@*@ggdzzjfderemp{@}@31018 Velasco Court of Appealsfrjp{@rxhml@@@R@grp{@Roma,Napoleon edReyes,Dominador dhrp{@ekedllejehrhhp{@(@l@@eddrhp{@hedd~(@l@@vhgdepem27200 vda. de PrecillagfpNarciso km@@@mmggp@@gddghpkedeheeeehgghddeddgR@b@whm@b@@gdd}}kedepem33410 Espino Cleofe qfpkqdxed@@2@qgpSolicitorGeneraleeAntonio,Felix/ Bausa,Francisco dqhpeeeelekdehqqedd2@@gefqeddgefz2@@zjfdep0p@emq@31012 People fpCarandang ls|d0p@@Pz@hdgp@@0p@SolicitorGeneralAntonio,Felix Timog,Pastor/Buegedhpser,Magno 0p@hhelkkdkh|h0p@ddged@@|hdd0p@@@gediighdepem{@{@36505 C.N. Hodges Espayos fpl{@}ded@@@@gp{@Gellada&Asc geAlmase,Teodoro/Lastimosa,Glori dhp{@degeeleeeh}em{@@@ڻ@eed}e{@ggedu@@ڻ@ukeden|em35027 Virata gfnAquino |mnub@@@heggn |@R@|SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli Cruz,Jr,Narciso gddghn|gkeelleeehgg|uhddgefgT@@|uhddR@@gdf~~jgdeneme@g@31569 Padilla Court of Appealswfnme@dhdl@@@(@wgne@delRosario,Floreedntino Atienza,Antonio dwhne@eegeleeeehwwhhe@(@l@@eddwhe@heddv@l@@ledek@eg@@38161 Bello fkCourt of Appealsg@l@ƻ@@eegk@@Martinez&Martinez OfoftheSolicitorggdhkGeneral,Dept.o @eeeeeeeeleeehe@eeed@l@@ee@@l@ƻ@ggdkkoedekhgȈ@@32613 People Ferrer fkhȈ@wdhdb@@@(@gkȈ@SolicitorGeneralgeMendoza,Esteli dhkȈ@eeehlmeddeedehweddȈ@8@b@gedwhȈ@ddgedi8@b@iledekȈ@hg@32614 People fkFerrer hwdȈ@b@@hdgk@(@Ȉ@SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli gedhkȈ@eeehlmeddeedehweȈ@ddged(@b@whddȈ@(@b@gediiledewegy@p|@37427 Chewplex (Philippines) Inc. Pamatianfwj}y@oddhd@ |@R@gwy@eddhwdy@hhhhlikkhhkhhohddy@R@@eddohy@ddedd~R@@~khdew@eg(@32818 Cornejo fwSecretary of Justice jr@@@@hegw@@@edfhw@kkeeddddeleehrh@heef2@@p@rhh@2@@p@edflzigdefegw@x@30307 People Feliciano fflsw@|dngd@@@gfw@SolicitorGeneralegMakasiar,Felix Sarte,Jose dhfw@eeeeeldeeeeeh|gddw@@@ged|gw@ddegdi@@inedefx@eg0{@31503 Feati University Faculty Club ffFeati Universitylsdx@*@@edgf@2@x@CiprianoCid&Asc Abad,Antonio ggdhfx@geeheheeledehex@ddggd2@*@eddx@2@*@ggdzznedeeegf@X@35546 Aquino, Jr. Enrile xfemuf@tdedb@@@y@xgef@gedxhef@ehllheheeeehxxthddf@y@@eedxtdf@ddeedhy@b@hmfdeef@egX@35538 Roces yfeEnrile mutdf@b@@edyge@y@f@gedyhef@ehllheheeeehyythf@ddeedyy@@tdddf@y@b@eedhhmfdeeegf@X@35539 Diokno Enrile zfemuf@tdedb@@@y@zgef@gedzhef@ehllheheeeehzzthddf@y@@eedztdf@ddeedhy@b@hmfdeef@egX@35540 Soliven {feEnrile mutdf@b@@ed{ge@y@f@ged{hef@ehllheheeeeh{{thf@ddeed{y@@tdddf@y@b@eedhhmfdeeegf@X@35547 Enrique Voltare Garcia II Ramos }femuf@tdedb@@@y@}gef@ged}hef@ehllheheeeeh}}thddf@y@@eed}tdf@ddeedhy@b@hmfdeef@egX@35556 Veronica L. Yuyitung ~feEnrile mutdf@b@@ed~ge@y@f@ged~hef@ehllheheeeeh~~thf@ddeed~y@@tdddf@y@b@eedhhmfdeeegf@X@35567 DoronilaEnrile femuf@tdedb@@@y@gef@gedhef@ehllheheeeehthddf@y@@eedtdf@ddeedhy@b@hmfdeef@egX@35571 Guiao feEnrile mutdf@b@@edge@y@f@gedhef@ehllheheeeehthf@ddeedy@@tdddf@y@b@eedhhmfdeeegf@X@35573 Rondon Enrile femuf@tdedb@@@y@gef@gedhef@ehllheheeeehthddf@y@@eedtdf@ddeedhy@b@hmfdezeg30978 Medina sfzYan mql@@@xhesgzy@Mutuc,Amelito SolicitorGeneraleedshzMakasiar,Felix eeleddedeeehssqhmeddsR@l@@qhey@l@@eefhhkedezhg@m@@m@30380 Galeon Galeon fzny@m@ded@{@@R@gz@m@gmdhz@m@eeelmeeeeeehwgdd@m@R@@eddwg@m@ddedd~R@@~medez@hm@26112 Republicfzde los Angeles hdd@@hdgz@R@@eddhzd@mmmmmldddlhwh@ddeddR@b@whdd@R@b@edf~~dfdeyhfw@x@37504 Escay Court of Appealsfypvw@wdedl@@@$@gyw@eddhyw@eleeehhddw@@l@eddhw@heddv@b@l@}hedex0q@egu@40004 Aquino, Jr. fxCommission on Elections eqd0q@b@@ddgx@q@0q@Tanada,Lorenzo/Tanada,Renato/T SolicitorGeneraleefhxMendoza,Esteli 0q@ghhlhehhhhehqd0q@ddeed i@b@qddd0q@ i@b@eefffnedexegu@v@32042 People Benito fxfqu@dngd@@P@gxu@egdhxu@gegleeeehehgddu@P@@dgdgu@ddegdiP@@imedex{@hg|@26321 City of Cebu fxMendoza f}rd{@@@hdgx@R@{@CityAttorneyPacquiao,Nazario/A Ruiz,Fernando edehx{@eedhldlkkeehrh{@ddegd@@rhdd{@R@@ede~~ihdewheg37201 Magtoto Manguerra ffwhggdhdf@z@@fgwhAbeleda,Felipe eeRoxas,Alan/SolicitorGeneralMen dfhwhellleeheeeehffhqhdd0y@@egdfhqhddegdd0y@@hlgdewheg37202 Magtoto gfwManguerra hggd@z@hdfggw@hAbeleda,Felipe Roxas,Alan/SoliceedghwitorGeneralMen hellleeheeeehgghqhddegdg0y@@hqhdd0y@@egddhlgdewheg37424 Simeon Villaluzhfwhggdhdf@ |@@hgwhMisa,Joaquin eeSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli dhhwhellleeheeeehhhhqhdd0y@@egdhhqhddegdd0y@@hlgdewheg38929 People ifwIsnani hggd@@edfigw@hSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli OrganoLawOf gedihwhellleeheeeehiihqeddggdi0y@@hqedd0y@@ggddhlgdeweg@Є@37364 Aquino, Jr. Military Commission No. 2 fwim@qdddeb@@@gw@Tanada,Salonga,Oeerdonez,Gonzale SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli fhw@dhhlhfeekeeehqhdd@py@@eedqh@ddeeddpy@@hmfdeseee29130 Development Bank of the Phil. tfsMirang ll}d@D@hdtgs@@Avancena,Jesus/Estrella,Hilari Desquitado,Roquegedthseheleehtt}hddgddt@@}hdd@@gefuuiedepeg29274 Evangelista Jarenciowfpoqddeds@@wgpSolicitorGeneralggBarredo,Antoni Ejercito,Gregorio/Chavez,Felix dwhpgehlddeeeedehwwqddd i@b@gedwqedsdggdd@dledepPq@egr@40779 Garcia fpThe Faculty Admission Committ ordPq@b@@ddgp@R@Pq@Garcia,EpicharisBenzon,Villegas,eddhpZarraga,Narcis Pq@kdeheleeeeeehrdPq@ddeed i@b@rdddPq@q@b@eed~fmfdenee29972 Carbonell Court of Appealsqfne~dedl@@@(@qgnTolentino,Garciagd,Cruz&Reyes Guevarra,Guillermo dqhnǹeheleehqqNjee(@l@@gddqǕeegddv(@l@@viedell@ego@23587 Ramirez flCourt of Appealsjnl@l@@@neegl@l@Quisumbing,Norberto/Ordones,Se SolicitorGeneralggdhlAlafriz,Arturo l@ldlkkdeeleehel@eggd@l@@eel@@l@@ggdkkhidelegl@o@23588 Ramirez Court of Appealsfljnl@neel@@@@gll@Quisumbing,Norbeggrto/Ordones,Se SolicitorGeneralAlafriz,Arturo dhll@ldlkkdeeleeheel@@l@@ggdel@eggdk@l@@khideit@eg }@44640 Sanidad fiCommission on Elections npqdt@b@@ddgi@ i@t@gddhit@hhlhlhlghehqdt@dddeef i@qhddt@ i@eefffkgdeiegt@ }@44684 Guzman Commission on Elections finpt@qdddb@@@ i@git@gddhit@hhlhlhlghehqddddt@ i@eefqht@ddeeff i@fkgdeit@eg }@44714 GonzalesfiCommission on Elections npqdt@b@@ddgi@ i@t@gddhit@hhlhlhlghehqdt@dddeef i@qhddt@ i@eefffkgdezigr@s@2074 Secretary of Justice Marcos fzhzr@ded@@9@gzr@eddhzr@delgeeeeeehdddr@:@@edddr@ddedd:@@ledeyeg22257 Go Yu Tak Wai qfyVivo i}dn@hdqgy@r@Fabre,Pedro AssistantSolicitggeqhyorGeneralZabal kellekeelehqq}hddggdqr@@}hddr@@ggdggiidexef@c@d@42184 Trans-Philippines, Inc. Court of Appealsfxk@c@qneel@@@R@gx@c@gddhx@c@gheleehqeh@c@@l@@gddqe@c@egdd~@l@@tiedew@@eg@31582 People fwVistido n~|d@@@gdgw@P@@@SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli RamonA.Gonzales&egdhwAsc @@eekeekeleeeeehóf@@ddegdP@@|gdd@@P@@egdiingdevhgh@Ȁ@47245 dela Llana Commission on Elections fvpmh@qdhd@@@ i@gvh@eefhvh@elheeleeeeehqdddh@ i@b@gedqdh@ddeeff i@b@fmfdevЀ@eg@47329 Hidalgo fvMarcos pmqdЀ@@@hdgv@ i@Ѐ@eefhvЀ@elheeleeeeehqdЀ@ddeef i@b@qdddЀ@ i@b@eefffmfdeumee31490 RepublicBisaya Land Transportation Co gfumej}dnmd@@R@ggumSolicitorGeneralmdAntonio,Felix/ Francisco,Vicente/Quisumbing,N dghumeldeeeehggmhddR@@gdfgm{hddgdd~R@@~iedeuee29618 Bisaya Land Transportation Co kfuGeronimoemdn@hdkgu@R@Cuenco,Antonio Bengzon,Jose/Beneddkhugzon,Villegas, eldeeeehkkhddeddkR@@hddR@@edd~~iedeseg47771 Peralta Commission on Elections hfsgordedb@@@`@hgsPeralta,Pedro gdSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli dhhseelheeleeeeehhhqhdd i@@eedhqhddeefm i@@fnfdeseg47803 David ifsCommission on Elections gordb@@edigs@`@Garcia,Jr,Nemesio/Melchor,Rodr SolicitorGeneralgddihsMendoza,Esteli eelheeleeeeehiiqhddeedi i@@qhdd i@@eefmfnfdeseg47816 Youth Democratic Movement Commission on Elections kfsgordedb@@@`@kgsRaulGonzalez&AscgdSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli dkhseelheeleeeeehkkqhdd i@@eedkqhddeefm i@@fnfdeseg47767 In the Matter of Petition for lfsNone gordb@@edlgs@`@delaLlana,Gualberto gddlhseelheeleeeeehllqhddeedl i@@qhdd i@@eefmfnfdeseg47791 Buenafe Commission on Elections mfsgordedb@@@`@mgsBuenafe,B. gdSolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli dmhseelheeleeeeehmmqhdd i@@eedmqhddeefm i@@fnfdeseg47827 Fajardo nfsCommission on Elections gordb@@edngs@`@Cueva,Binay/Fernandez&Asc SolicitorGeneralgddnhsMendoza,Esteli eelheeleeeeehnnqhddeedn i@@qhdd i@@eefmfnfdeshgh@m@47883 Lakas ng Bayan Commission on Elections ~fsg}h@qded@@@`@~gsh@deLeon,Primitivoed/Gonzales,Nept SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli d~hsh@hlleggdeeeeeh~~qhddh@ i@@eed~qhh@ddeedm i@@fmfdesu@egv@39380 Lina fsPurisimahrrdnu@@edgs@2@u@Salcedo,Honesto/Salcedo,Pantal Narvaez,Levy ggdhsu@eeheleeeeeeehreu@ddggd2@@reddu@2@@ggdzzoederef33935 Maria Cristina Fertilizer Pla Maria Cristina Fertilizer Cor lfrioqdhd*@@@2@lgrSeno,Juanario ggCapco,Florentinodlhrleeeeehllqdh2@b@*@ggdlqhddggdz2@*@ziederef e@32529 People yfrTy Sui Wong ip|d@ |@gdygr@@OfoftheSolicitorGeneral DakilaF.Castro&Agedyhrsc/Dacanay,A. eeeleehyygddgedy@@|gdd@@gediiiedepruhf29949 Misamis Lumber Co., Inc.Sec. of Agr. & Nat. Resources gfprkjqdmb@@@@@ggprCapistrano,Dionimmsio ALvia,Estelito/AssistantSolici mghpreleeeehggrqdddR@b@mdfgrqhgffftĒ@b@@piedepweg32126 People hfpTalingdan wkj|d@hdhgp@P@wgedhhpwdldleldeeeeeehhhw|hddgedhP@@w|gddP@@gediikgdepef26295 Catangcatang Legayadalfpkrehl@@@@$@lgpgddlhpeeeleehlleh$@l@@gddlehgddv$@l@@viedepef36637 Mendoza nfpCourt of Appealskrl@@@hengpt@$@Encarnacion,Demetrio/Antiporda Gonzales,Norberteddnhpo eheleehnnhgeddn(@l@@he(@l@@eddvviedepeg44060 People Paragsa sfpkx|eel@@@@@sgpegdshp͹kehkekeleeeehss͐ee@l@@egds͐eeegdi@l@@ilhdepp@gg@q@P60 AmoladorfpFelicidario kxp@ƻ@@hhgp@@p@gddhpp@lhheeeeeeeeehdp@ddgdd@dddp@@@gddoedepefv@w@40295 Sison Panramuyen fpkv@rdhd@@@@gpv@Domingo&Domingo edG.J.delaLlana/M.S.Gerongfhpv@eeeleehrhddv@@@edfrhv@ddedfl@@liedenn@egp@30375 Escribano fnAvila mpodn@b@@edgn@t@n@Diokno,Jose Sicat,M.C. egdhnn@elhleeedeeehqhn@ddeedt@@qhddn@t@@egdsslfdenef@`@44042 Eugenio Torrijosfnnm@odhdb@@@@gn@Colet,Galimba&Asgdc OfoftheSolicitorGeneral dhn@egeledhohh@@@edfoh@hedfl@@lhedems@hgu@25885 Luzon Brokerage Co., Inc. fmMaritime Building Co., Inc. otds@b@@ddgm@@s@gddhms@hkelelellllehwhs@ddgdd@@whdds@@b@gddttikdemegPx@y@33345 Bagajo Marave fmoxPx@ee@ڻ@h@h@h@gmPx@Bacolod,DiosdadoggOfoftheSolicitorGeneral dhmPx@ellelhlhekeeheePx@h@@ڻ@ggdePx@eggdih@@ڻ@ikidemy@eg@34854 Pamil fmTeleron oxdy@@0@edgm@@y@Lagunay,Urbano Cimagala,Cristetgedhmo y@helhhhlheeeehey@ddgdd@@eddy@@@gedklnfdemeg@@45490 People Sabio, Sr. fmox@dhdƻ@@@@gm@egEdmilao,Roque dhm@elelkleeeeeehhdd@@ƻ@egdh@ddegdk@ƻ@klhdem@eg@45711 Liap fmCourt of Appealsox@l@ƻ@@eegm@@Ablan,Santiago&Fornier/Jimenez SolicitorGeneralggdhmMendoza,Esteli @eeelkleeeeeehe@eggd@l@ƻ@ee@@l@ƻ@ggdkkmgdemeg@@42971 Lagua Cusi, Jr. fmox@ded@@@@gm@Asis,Wilfred ggGoc-Ong,Cirilo dhm@eeelkleeeeeehhdd@@@eedh@ddeedk@@kmgdem؄@eg@34248 People fmMolleda oydn؄@@gdgm@P@؄@gedhm؄@eeklekkeeeeehg؄@ddegdP@@gdd؄@P@@egdiilhdelegh@k@33079 Philippine Virginia Tobacco A de los Angeles {flpoh@dxhd@@@{glh@egd{hlh@eekekdleeeeh{{hddh@@@edd{hh@ddeddt@@tkgdek`h@egk@49112 Agustin fkEdu ffqd`h@b@@ddgk@ i@`h@LeovilloAgustinLawOf SolicitorGeneraleedhkMendoza,Esteli `h@eelejedeeeeeeehqh`h@ddeef i@+@qhdd`h@ i@+@eefffoedekeg`o@Pr@49705 Aratuc Commission on Elections fkfl`o@udhd@@@`@gk`o@Patajo,Lino edFernandez,Estanislao fhk`o@ledekedeeeedhkhuedd`o@`@@edduh`o@ddedfm`@@mlgdek`o@egPr@49709 Aratuc fkCommission on Elections flud`o@@@hdgk@`@`o@Patajo,Lino Fernandez,Estaniedfhkslao `o@ledekedeeeedhkhue`o@ddedd`@@uhdd`o@`@@edfmmlgdekeg`o@Pr@49717 Mandangan Commission on Elections fkfl`o@udhd@@@`@gk`o@Fernandez,Estaniedslao Patajo,Lino/OfoftheSolicitorGe fhk`o@ledekedeeeedhkhuedd`o@`@@edduh`o@ddedfm`@@mlgdek`o@egPr@49721 Mandangan fkCommission on Elections flud`o@@@hdgk@`@`o@Fernandez,Estanislao Patajo,Lino/OfofedfhktheSolicitorGe `o@ledekedeeeedhkhue`o@ddedd`@@uhdd`o@`@@edfmmlgdekhf`~@@49818 People Ramos fkfx`~@}dmd@k@@@Ǎgk`~@mmdhk`~@eheleeehwedd`~@ i@@egd}f`~@ddgedi@@ijedeief43540 Flores ufiWorkmen's Compensation Commis grީ@@@ehugi@@Velasco,Rolando Bengson,Denis&Avggduhiancena,Jesus ehlleeehuuehggfu@ީ@@eh@ީ@@gge{{ifdeeepgg690CF Nate Agana efeejddd@@:@egeegddeheeeheleedeeeeelheeeddd9@@gddeedddgdd9@@nfdeeepgg690CF Nate ffeAgana ejd@@ddfge@շ@egddfheeeheleedeeeeelhffedddgddfշ@@@edddշ@@@gddǡnfdeeefc@`d@33115 Vera Cusi, Jr. tfejc@zded@D@@T@tgec@Sumcad,Leonor/Sagerenas,Roberto OfoftheSolicitorGeneral dthec@hleeeehttzhddc@d@@egetzhc@ddegeqd@@qiedee@u@egv@22947 People feBorja kp|d@u@@@hdge@P@@u@Antonio,Manuel/Begdheangayan,Isidro @u@elheddeeeeeeeh|g@u@ddegdP@@|gdd@u@P@@egdiinedeeeg`z@0{@30101 People Coracheafekt`z@dgd@y@@@ge`z@SolicitorGeneralegAntonio,Felix Mendoza,Estelitodhe`z@gleedeeeeeeeehgdd`z@@@egdg`z@ddegdi@@ioedezethg99999 In the Matter of the Petition efzNone ekqdb@@ddegz@R@edddehzedekkkleeeedeeheeewdddeddeR@b@ewdddR@b@edd~~khdez~eg24740 RepublicJuan hfz~k}dgdu@@hgz~CelestinoC.Juan&egAsc SolicitorGeneral'sOf dhhz~fhiellddeeeeehhh~}gdud@egdh~}gdudegdd@dlfdezeg28104 People ifzMil kd@@hdigz@`@SolicitorGeneralAntonio,Felix/ Fernandez,Estaniegdihzslao elhedleeeedehiigddegdiP@@gddP@@egdiilfdezeg28105 People Mil kfzkdhd@@@`@kgzSolicitorGeneralegAntonio,Felix/ Fernandez,Estanislao dkhzelhedleeeedehkkgddP@@egdkgddegdiP@@ilfdezeg30354 People mfzEstante, Jr. k|d@@gdmgz@@SolicitorGeneralSalcedo,Leopoldoegdmhz/Miravite,Lore eekkdlleeleehmm|gddegdm@@ސgdd@@egdiijidezeg@p@33132 People Veloso y Militante fzlj@dgd@@@P@gz@egdhzd@leeedheeedeehgdd@P@@egdh@ddgediP@@imedez8@egȇ@31912 People fzDuaban l|d8@@@gdgz@P@8@SolicitorGeneralAntonio,Felix/ Barrot,Edilbertoggdhz8@lehhdeedeedeehg8@ddegdP@@gdd8@P@@egdiimedeyfg997 Abaigar Paz nfymnddd@@@@׷@ngyeddnhyddeligeeeeeehnnddd׷@@@eddndddedd׷@@@ledeys@egt@29979 People fyMada-I Santalanimds@@D@gdgy@`@s@SolicitorGeneralAntonio,Felix/ Chan,Manuel egdhys@eeddledeeeeehgs@ddged`@@gdds@`@@egdiiledeyeg@@32629 People Tabion fyn{@dgd@@P@gy@SolicitorGeneralegAntonio,Felix Atienza,Arturo dhy@geeldeeeedeeehhdd@P@@gedg@ddegdiP@@inedey@eg`@32690 People fyTanchicon{dx@@gdgy@P@@SolicitorGeneralNera,A. gedhyd@deleeeeeeeleehh@ddgedP@@gdd@P@@gediinfdeyefh@@49481 Gas Corporation of the Philip Inciong fyn{h@qhhe@@@@gyh@Tan,Jr,Bienvenideeo ActingSolicitorGeneralMendoza, fhyh@edeleeehqhheh@@@eedqhh@heegfd@@diedey @efh@48252 Enriquez, Sr. fyRepublicn @ީ@@@ehgy@@ @Enriquez,Jr,Domingo Navarro,L/ActingggehySolicitorGener @hleeeehe @hggd@ީ@@eh @@ީ@@gge{{iedex¡eg23545 Sichangco Board of Commissioners of Imm nfx¡okned@h@@r@ngx¡Mabanag,Elegir&Aeesc SolicitorGeneraldnhx¡elkekeeeeegeehnn¡}ehr@@h@eedn¡}eheefgr@@h@gngdex»eg28966 People ofxde la Cruz okd@h@gdogx@@»SolicitorGeneralMakasiar,Felix Gozon,Felipe/Belgedohxtran,Beltran&B »dkeleeeeeeeleehoo»gddgedo@@»gdd@@gediingdexeg30518 People Rabuya y Galletorfxokdhd@@@rgxSolicitorGeneralgeAntonio,Felix Narvasa,Andres drhxddglgdgeeeeeeehrrߐhdd@@gedrߐhddgedi@@inedexegd@31866 People sfxCaramonte ok|d@X@gdsgx@@SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli Montecillo,Victoegdshxrino gleeeeeeeeeeehss|gddegds@@|gdd@@egdiipedexegg@@i@35413 People Morales wfxokg@dgd@@@@wgxg@SolicitorGeneralegMendoza,Esteli Lagman,Edcel fwhxg@egllegekeeeelhwwgddg@@@gedwgg@ddegdi@@imhdex`l@eg@n@38094 People yfxDiamononokd`l@@gdygx@P@`l@SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli Maghari,Jose egdyhx`l@ekelelekeedeehyyg`l@ddegdyP@@gdd`l@P@@egdiilhdexeew@x@33240 Dacanay People fxoyw@ggl@@@n@P@gxw@egdhxw@eeeeleh}ggw@P@@ڻ@ggd}gw@gegdiP@l@@iiedex@egX@24670 Ortigas & Co., Limited Partne fxFeati Bank and Trust Co.pr}d@@hdgx@@@Ramirez&Ortigas Tanada,Teehankeeeddhx&Carreon@hdeeedeeeeleeh}h@ddedd(@@}hdd@(@@eddtvnedexeg@H@29451 People Alvaradofxpr@dgd@@@@gx@SolicitorGeneralegMakasiar,Felix Feria,Lugtu&Lao dhx@khedeeeekeleehgdd@@@egdg@ddegdi@@imgdexP@eg؂@29980 People fxAng pr|dP@@D@hdgx@@P@OfoftheSolicitorGeneral Mascario&Asc/Ocagedhxmpo,Primo/Tol dP@deleeeeeeeeeeh|gP@ddged@@|hddP@@@gediioedexeg@(@30966 People Bernalesfxpr@dgd@@@gx@egdhx@elhedeeeeeeeehgdd@@@egdg@ddegdi@@ioedex@egp@33228 People fxGuevarrapr|d@@t@hdgx@@@SolicitorGeneralMendoza,Esteli Pineda,Miguel gedhxd@deeeeleeeeeeeh|h@ddged@@|hdd@@@gediioedexeg@H@32571 People Pajarillo fxp@dgd@@P@gx@egTomacruz,Manuel dhx@kekldleeeeeeehgdd@P@@egdg@ddegdiP@@ilhdex@egH@32572 People fxPajarillo pd@@gdgx@P@@Tomacruz,Manuel egdhx@kekldleeeeeeehg@ddegdP@@gdd@P@@egdiilhdewfzeg38975 People Caguioa ffwfeu}deg@t@@R@fgwfAsst.ProvincialFegiscalVicente,A Amante,Edelmiro dfhwfeghekleeeeeeehfff}hddy@@egdff}hddegd~y@@hofdeweg25975 People ofwAdriano y Sanguesa ezdn@hdogw@@gedohwdehkehkefeehefhooϐgddgedo@@ϐhdd@@gediiofdewegd@`g@30413 People Lanseta wfwezd@dngd@@@wgw